Sunday, April 7, 2024

302
Comments
0.307
Avg Sentiment
125
Positive
128
Neutral
49
Negative
Sort by:
AnitaNYCApr 6, 2024, 11:00 PMpositive99%

Lots of fun, and a good Sunday BRAIN(TT)ER. Thanks, Tracy!

74 recommendations
Eric HouglandAustin TXApr 7, 2024, 3:35 AMpositive66%

If you’ve been wondering how Will Shortz is doing, he emceed the ACPT this weekend: <a href="https://tinyurl.com/hkysa7xy" target="_blank">https://tinyurl.com/hkysa7xy</a> I think there’s about 45 minutes of video before he shows up. He seems to be recovering well.

70 recommendations6 replies
sotto vocepnwApr 7, 2024, 3:49 AMpositive95%

@Eric Hougland Thank you so much for this. It's wonderful news! May he soon be completely recovered.

26 recommendations
Laurence of BessarabiaSanta MonicaApr 7, 2024, 4:05 AMpositive97%

@Eric Hougland thanks, great to see will speaking and doing so well.

14 recommendations
SPCincinnatiApr 7, 2024, 12:45 AMneutral51%

So the theme was EEZPPZ since EEONDOWNTHEROAD was a gimme to me. But oddly enough another theme could have been Trivia I’ve Never Even Heard Of (but maybe should). TABOURET, VOILE, STAYMAN, PUENTE, ENSOR,SINEBAR, EMILIO and ANTIHERO (as a Taylor Swift song) as a start—a long list for me for a Sunday. If I were like many commentators lately I suppose I would just say it’s the worst puzzle ever and blame it on the editors in Will’s absence. Instead I’m going to chalk it up to one of those days the constructor just has a wider experience than I do in those areas, or else dug further in their word bank to make a really tight clever theme work. So I'll just be grateful that today I got to learn a lot of new things and managed to get through the puzzle regardless, admittedly having to run through the alphabet a few times.

56 recommendations7 replies
Prof. Toru Tanakaeast coastApr 7, 2024, 1:51 AMpositive97%

@SP I always enjoy learning a new word when doing NYT crosswords. Today, it was TABOURET.

16 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 7, 2024, 2:10 AMneutral69%

@SP (Second shot. Not waiting around for some human to let the first one through next week.) It's me, hi, I'm the problem, it's me. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqN2qFvY64U" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqN2qFvY64U</a> You're welcome. !!! !!! !!! More emu filler...

8 recommendations
AZCaliforniaApr 7, 2024, 4:46 AMneutral70%

@SP I had a few as well, but I could guess STAYMAN from stamen and SINEBAR makes enough sense. Didn't love PUENTE crossed with ENSOR though, and putting serene instead of SEDATE messed up the TABOURET part, though CLAM helped clear that up.

3 recommendations
sotto vocepnwApr 7, 2024, 3:45 AMpositive88%

This is a beauty of a puzzle that was a complete joy to solve. More on that later. Someone in yesterday's comments mentioned Casey Kasem (thinking of him instead of Ryan Seacrest) and that's the only reason I knew it. It pays to read Wordplay! I don't remember who it was, but thank you. I had to get CINC from the crosses because I only know POTUS to be Commander in Chief. The sad part is that I then stared at CINC thinking it was some americanized version of the French "cinq" and, of course, I could make no sense of it. I shrugged my shoulders and carried on. It was only after seeing the letters again in the column that it hit me, and then a huge head slap hit me as well. Doh! It made me smile to see MEAN for "intend" since that was my entry yesterday, before "hope." It's really interesting how "hope" or MEAN can stand in for "intend" but in slightly different ways. English is a phenomenal language, with all its twists and turns. As I started out by saying, I enjoyed this beautiful puzzle to the max. At each Double Duty entry, I stopped to take it in, in awe of the mind that created it. The whole solve was a joy, from start to finish. Thank you, Ms. Gray, for this veritable gem!

52 recommendations
EdHalifax, Nova ScotiaApr 7, 2024, 3:41 AMpositive63%

Fun puzzle. I'd never heard of a sine bar but now I know it's the sine qua non for measuring or setting angles. But I guess I've just gone off on a tangent.

43 recommendations
LewisAsheville, NCApr 7, 2024, 11:22 AMpositive97%

A just-right chaser to yesterday’s deep dive. Coursing through Tracey’s puzzle was like tubing down the river, engaged, relaxed, and happy. There were lovely answers that surprisingly, to me, have never shown up in the 80 years of NYT crosswords – ARE YOU UP, A SIGHT FOR SORE EYES, BLACK EYED PEAS, USE IT OR LOSE IT. Other new answers (there were 11 in total) included NY YANKEE, QUESO DIP, and SEIZE THE MOMENT. New answers mean new clues, all sparking the grid, keeping things interesting. I liked seeing CLAM up, and my ear worm for the day is “Life is a TABOURET, old chum”. WETHE is a lovely dook. Plus, there were some areas of resistance that satisfied my brain’s work ethic. Ahhh. Thank you, Tracy. This was the BBs knEE for me today.

39 recommendations1 replies
Nat KNYCApr 7, 2024, 1:23 PMpositive74%

@Lewis, “Just right chaser” indeed. What a great, pithy description.

7 recommendations
LewisAsheville, NCApr 6, 2024, 11:06 PMpositive96%

What a lovely puzzle to COMPOO! Et tu, emu.

36 recommendations
ZackChicagoApr 7, 2024, 9:23 PMpositive79%

Late to finish today... I'm of two minds. First, I loved the theme and how the double clues worked. Cracked that early and had a fun time finding those answers. Filled the puzzle pretty quickly, but with low confidence. Then, my second impression is that there are WAY too many natick or natick-ish crosses in this puzzle. If I don't know the name of a particular kind of stool or the name of a particular artist, I have a square I need to run the alphabet for. One of those isn't really a problem... but if you add in the following proper name crosses you have a problem: Iraqi city / Jewelry brand name Curtain fabric / metrology tool name Gymnast surname / apple variety name Musical notation name / Obscure Japanese vegetable And those are just the ones that had me scratching my head. I'm sure things I took for granted were a challenge for others. When you have 3, 4 or 5 of these crosses, you end up needing to get lucky or run the alphabet for hundreds of combinations. Sure, you can infer that 33D is either ALI or ALY, but that multiplies the number of alphabet runs by 2. 18D is probably a consonant, so again, it isn't 26 letters to try, but we're already up to 40+ and we have 3 more trouble spots to include. If you don't know either of the words, just just have to run the letters.. there is no puzzling out the name of a city you don't know and a brand name you don't know... you need to just try all the vowels. Not impressed.

36 recommendations1 replies
BeccaIllinoisApr 7, 2024, 11:34 PMpositive61%

@Zack You said exactly what I was feeling. Even the details. I love the theme, tho it took me a bit to catch on to its exact nature, & there's a lot to like about this puzzle but you said it exactly: too many Naticky crosses. One point: if 2 squares need alphabet runs, it's not just 2x the runs— it SQUARES it. 26 x 26. With 3-4 up-for-grabs squares it's in the 1000's. Even w/some clear vowels, it's impossible. The 9 billion names of God. I tried SOOO many runs, peeked on google just to confirm stuff— yes, it's riddle me REE (never heard of but had crosses), & yes, UDO's a veg, etc, but then I found it's TABOURET not TABOULET, & thought I might just cede the streak. Put the R in anyway… still no-go! Then peeked at Comments (not the column), if folks were screamimg "Natick City!' maybe I'd keep the streak. Saw STAYMAN (I had STAiMAN, I'd tried Y to no avail), & I thot I'd Check Puzzle to forfeit the streak but didn't, way too big a decision for me today ha, & I put in the Y. Feeble 'Yay'. Earlier amid the flyspecking I'd added slashes to all the rebus squares, then undid 'em… It's too bad bc the theme is lovely, & the puzzle is fine except those really are just what you said, possibly-un-parse-able Naticky crosses. IMO that made it kind of Saturday-level difficulty on a Sunday puzzle… I might very soon just randomly "check" a xwrd to bounce the streak, which ofc would set me behind in restarting it but we'll see. It's too bad. Cuz it was quite a witty & original theme.

12 recommendations
AndrewOttawaApr 6, 2024, 11:58 PMneutral46%

Well, that was a big change from Saturday. Hopefully commenters have had time to calm down. There seemed to be record numbers of angry solvers for a challenging Saturday puzzle. Those who complained that "intend" did not equate to "hope" got their preferred "mean" today. Todays puzzle reminded me of a ditty that my mother used to recite: YYUR YYUB ICUR YY4ME (Too wise you are / Too wise you be / I see you are / Too wise for me) Something to amuu the emuu...

32 recommendations2 replies
JoPerth, AustraliaApr 7, 2024, 11:47 AMpositive71%

@Andrew my mum used to say the same poem. Funnily enough it came to mind the other day. We also used to say Me (I) Heart (Love) Sheep (Ewe/you) I have not thought of that in years.

4 recommendations
MAR1VA, USAApr 7, 2024, 6:19 PMneutral70%

@Andrew Your ditty reminded me of a favorite from my mother: M R ducks M R not O S M R, C M E D B D wings L I B, M *R* ducks

1 recommendations
DawnWSeattleApr 6, 2024, 11:52 PMpositive98%

A cleverly-constructed Sunday puzzle that was fun to do.Thank you!

30 recommendations
SteveBoulder COApr 7, 2024, 3:31 PMnegative81%

What good is sitting with a back on your stool? Let your back ache all day. Life is a Tabouret, old chum, Sit on the Tabouret.

30 recommendations1 replies
MinOrange County, NYApr 8, 2024, 12:05 AMpositive97%

@Steve Thanks for the smile - it is certainly more refreshing than the complaints.

1 recommendations
MichaelMDApr 7, 2024, 5:33 PMpositive99%

Not only do I LOVE rebus puzzles, I cannot wait for each Thursday morning in anticipation that it may be a rebus. A Sunday rebus is a super welcome bonus!

30 recommendations
MichaelMDApr 7, 2024, 12:04 AMpositive99%

On a scale of 1-10, my enjoyment level for Ms. Gray's grid maxed out at 20! Lots of fun!

26 recommendations
Pax Ahimsa GethenSan Francisco, CaliforniaApr 7, 2024, 7:08 PMneutral64%

Though I wouldn't call this puzzle "fast-paced", it was a BREE after yesterday's slog.

26 recommendations
Cat Lady MargaretMaineApr 6, 2024, 11:46 PMpositive51%

After the AGONEE some suffered with the Saturday puzzle… I hope there were no further MALADD with this fun Sunday. Cheers y’all.

24 recommendations
CCNYNYApr 7, 2024, 1:25 PMpositive79%

Great clue for FARM. Nice Sunday rebus! Not too crunchy, not too sweet. And, I swear Joel is messing with us. Is TIVO making a comeback, or what? And yesterday the debate over “Intend” - HOPE Today, “Mean”- INTEND! SEACREST yesterday, KASEM today! And CABOOSES. I’m sure there were more. I don’t know what the intention is, and I certainly don’t mind. But curious if they’re repeating answers to build confidence in newer solvers? Reminds me that ages ago, the Oreo of the puzzle was Oleo. Could barely go 2 days without it. And Arabian seaport was practically required as a clue. It’s interesting to me, anyway. I’m sounding old. CC out.

23 recommendations3 replies
LindaKYApr 7, 2024, 2:50 PMpositive93%

@CCNY The clue to FARM was too good! I had FA_M and still had to do the (silent) alphabet song to figure out the third letter. That it was paired with the tricky "Mains" doubled the pleasure! Another "Double Duty"!

6 recommendations
GrantDelawareApr 7, 2024, 3:08 PMnegative58%

@CCNY "SEACREST yesterday, KASEM today!" I noticed that too. It got me wondering, how do they even calculate the Top 40 anymore? Consider that it used to be based on sales of singles and phone-in requests to DJs. Now there are countless sources for music, how would you track them all? And why bother? It seems so antiquated, but apparently people still listen to "terrestrial" radio, and AT40 is still very popular.

6 recommendations
KatieOntario, CanadaApr 7, 2024, 3:26 PMpositive52%

@CCNY Funny, I read the clue for 29D and thought, is oleo back!?

4 recommendations
MikeMunsterApr 7, 2024, 4:07 AMpositive96%

The beach's webpage is a site for shore eyes. (It's a great place to surf.)

22 recommendations
Henry SuWashington DCApr 6, 2024, 10:56 PMpositive72%

Very clever, Ms. Gray. If there were a vote, I'd say the II have it. Fairly EEyPPy. I had a little trouble only in the NE, where I had to change highiq to IQTEST, realize that 25A isn't S___ ON (two words), and pull ENSOR out of the back of my mind to resolve the Naticky crossing with TABOURET (a TIL for me too).

20 recommendations1 replies
VislanderGreensboro NCApr 7, 2024, 10:20 AMpositive50%

@Henry Su Nearly the exact same experience. I saved the ENSO_, TABOU_ET crossing for my last entry and got it on the third try. Lucky for me that no further flyspecking was required.

4 recommendations
StevenSalt Lake CityApr 7, 2024, 5:24 AMpositive82%

My appreciation for this Sunday puzzle. (GG)LOUISEITSTHE(BB)KNEES cc: emu handler

20 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiApr 7, 2024, 2:15 PMpositive95%

A welcome respite, I must say! Clever gimmick and fresh fill, SIX themers!, and a couple of new words. What's not to like? (Okay, a tiny nit: for 20A..."Light-weight curtain fabric"....this was the perfect opportunity to force SamE to acknowledge NINON--which I stitched up for front-room drapery back in the day. Oh, well.) Just had breakfast pancakes; I had suggested to DHubby that addiing shredded coconut and pecans to the batter would be tasty. The first bite was quite a surprise: he didn't chop up the pecans. Would have made a good April Fools' gag. New to me: TABOURET and WAVE SKI. Not likely to encounter the latter, but I've used a TABOURET often, all unknowingly. Two new words in Japanese! Domo arigato. For the bird's name that begins with a silent letter, Tracy, one day would you please, please use PTARMIGAN? CINC was of course an instant gimme. On the road down to Honolulu, you passed a little sign as the highway approached Pearl Harbor; it read: CINCPACFLT --> (That little memory is taking up much-needed room in my brain...) Second day for CABOOSE(s)....Hope we've seen the back of that one, now. Adieu, mes amis!

20 recommendations
KimbleNashvilleApr 7, 2024, 6:25 AMpositive89%

Meet James ENSOR Belgium's famous painter Dig him up and shake his hand Appreciate the man --They Might Be Giants, 1994 <a href="https://youtu.be/NA0FJ3akfUs" target="_blank">https://youtu.be/NA0FJ3akfUs</a> Fun puzzle, although the Ensor/tabouret intersection would've been tricky without this lovely song.

18 recommendations3 replies
Nancy J.NHApr 7, 2024, 11:14 AMpositive91%

@Kimble Ha ha! That's what gave it to me also. I get some of my best information from songs and the comics.

5 recommendations
Eric HouglandAustin TXApr 7, 2024, 3:06 PMneutral61%

@Kimble That song is probably the only reason I know anything about James ENSOR.

1 recommendations
Bob T.New York, NYApr 7, 2024, 6:30 PMpositive66%

@Kimble omg I have that album and had completely forgotten that song. thx. Now I have to listen to Particle Man.

2 recommendations
RandolphFarmlandApr 7, 2024, 2:01 AMpositive88%

Well, I'm not sure that I had a rollicking good time, but I got through. It is an impressive puzzle. I got the rebuses, mostly from the fairly easy double letter down crosses, E.g. NYANKEE for 72D. But 74A ending in ...THEYY made no sense to my brain. II think I expected the rebus to be identical in the crosses. Although I think I've maybe encountered and not understood similar rebus crossings in earlier puzzles. I will get smart someday (wishful thinking). The rebus comment is not a complaint, The rebuses were very clever, much more interesting than YY across and down in what I cited above. Now I understand rebusdom a little better. I did find some of the trivia (my take, not necessarily anyone else's) obscure. But I'm no purist and after I've filled what I can I'm happy to use DuckDuckGo for inspiration. Generally a lookup makes an entire area clearer. And looking at a map of Iraq and following the Tigris looking for a city that satisfied my crossings was pure joy - I really love maps. And for lookups I draw the line at those spoilsport NYTimes crosswordd clue results. Final thought: I will probably enter ALI for Olympian ALY many more times, did it before, did it today, will certainly do it next time.

17 recommendations3 replies
ChrisSan FranciscoApr 7, 2024, 2:45 AMneutral85%

@Randolph 74A: a word to the YY (wise)

0 recommendations
Eric HouglandAustin TXApr 7, 2024, 3:26 AMneutral85%

@Randolph Every single time the Olympic gymnast is in the clue, I type ALi first. I should know by now that her name is ALY and that if the grid needed an ALi, the clue would mention Muhammad or Laila. Today, it wasn’t until I figured out the STAYMAN/stamen homophone that I got YY to Ms Raisman’s name.

6 recommendations
David ConnellWeston CTApr 7, 2024, 12:14 PMneutral71%

@Randolph - if you add -crossword to your search field it will eliminate crossword specific results.

0 recommendations
Hope LevavBronx, New YorkApr 7, 2024, 3:29 AMpositive99%

Super fun and very clever--after a very tiresome Saturday grid. I was especially happy to see Casey KASEM show up today, as he had been my first thought yesterday, for the answer that turned out to be Ryan SEACREST.

17 recommendations
ad absurdumchicagoApr 7, 2024, 2:40 PMpositive79%

I hope(intend?) we can all agree that if you only watch one reality show set in a Florida tattoo parlor, it should be "Miami Ink"! ("St. Pete Pigment" is a close second) Very fun theme! Took me about half the time as yesterday's puzzle(which, sorry, I loved). EMILIO Pucci seemed like a name I'd soon forget until I googled "Pucci print" as @sotto voce yyly suggested. Wowza! Why has nobody made an odd-couple sitcom about Pucci and James Ensor sharing an atelier?!?! Too cute! No, wait! Even better: they're coproprietors of a tattoo parlor! *cc himself out*

17 recommendations1 replies
MikeMiamiApr 7, 2024, 4:29 PMneutral80%

@ad absurdum ...where everyone sits on tabourets.

4 recommendations
AmyCTApr 7, 2024, 7:18 PMpositive71%

Yes, I ran the alphabet at Ensor/Tabouret. Just glad that was the only one.

17 recommendations
Senex Sr.USAApr 6, 2024, 11:47 PMnegative95%

What an awful slog. Please never inflict another puzzle like this on us again.

16 recommendations2 replies
JoeNJApr 6, 2024, 11:54 PMpositive94%

@Senex Sr. Personally, I'd like for the NYT and Tracy Gray to keep inflicting on us great puzzles like this one. It wasn't perfect, but the theme was fun and there were plenty of lively entries that I appreciated.

86 recommendations
AndrewOttawaApr 7, 2024, 12:52 PMneutral72%

@Senex Sr. I'm thinking that your comment might have been intended for the Saturday puzzle. Since your comment was posted about an hour after the relase of the Sunday puzzle, it couldn't have been that much of a slog for you. On the other hand, your comment would have fitted in easily amongst all the other frustrated commenters who posted about the Saturday puzzle.

11 recommendations
JoanArizonaApr 7, 2024, 12:09 AMneutral43%

My times solving the Saturday and Sunday puzzles won't reveal the full story. I spent far less time on the Saturday, as I began cheating right away, and cheated twenty seven times. However, I loved spending time on the Sunday puzzle. Even so, I got it all filled and didn't hear the music. I was able to find two of my mistakes on my own, but couldn't detect the third, so I brought up the answer pdf. Alas, I'd spelled the Iraqi city as 'Samaria', but TIL, there's two cities with a similar name. 'Samaria' is in the West Bank of Palestine. This was a fun puzzle. I hope to see many more puzzles from Tracy Gray.

16 recommendations3 replies
Kris TMinneapolisApr 7, 2024, 1:48 AMneutral67%

@Joan The fable turned into a novel, Appointment in Samarra, helps me remember the difference.

7 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 7, 2024, 1:57 AMneutral88%

@Joan Samaria is not a city. It is the northern portion of the West Bank, generally north of Ramallah, or the portion of that region north where Israel proper bulges eastward towards Jerusalem. Israeli sources call the West Bank "Judea and Samaria", with Judea being the southern part of the region. The implication is that it was part of Biblical Israel. There was an ancient city in Samaria with the same name, but that was a long time ago.

2 recommendations
Pani KorunovaPortugalApr 7, 2024, 4:48 AMnegative53%

@Joan I’m with you about Saturday. I cheated so much yesterday that I expected to be served with divorce papers 🤣🤣🤣

24 recommendations
StavrosColoradoApr 7, 2024, 12:43 AMpositive96%

For me, the contrast of Saturday and Sunday puzzles makes each that much more enjoyable. The context of the progression of all past puzzles enhances the present experience. The flow of challenge and ease. The variations in creative ideas from the constructors. I really appreciated the comments yesterday. Some so edgy and raw. Great insights into what makes an effective puzzle. It all brings me to see more than I might have on my own.

16 recommendations
Pani KorunovaPortugalApr 7, 2024, 4:40 AMpositive84%

Tracy, thanks for the much-needed confidence boost after yesterday’s debacle. I always enjoy that aha moment after you are certain of an answer but it doesn’t fit. The frustration followed by the lightbulb 💡 is the mental workout I’m here for. EONDOWNTHEROAD indeed! This time it happened in two varieties, which was unexpected and welcome. ARTICIRCLE and MIAMINK had me flummoxed until I realized a second game was afoot. Side note — living outside the city in Portugal is a real delight. I have had to learn the language and customs, which makes it all the more interesting. However, you won’t find an OMELETTE anywhere! The typical Portuguese breakfast is a pastel (pastry) with coffee. That’s it! The only American breakfast I eat is made in my casa. 🤣. The Portuguese lunches and dinners are quite tasty, though!

16 recommendations2 replies
Al in PittsburghPittsburgh, PAApr 7, 2024, 5:30 AMpositive71%

@Pani Korunova I hope that you get to hear some live fado as well. Perhaps with a sharp vinho verde or an earthy red. My Amalia Rodriguez CDs get a lot of play time.

5 recommendations
Pani KorunovaPortugalApr 7, 2024, 4:27 PMpositive98%

@Al in Pittsburgh I have seen Fado in Lisbon. Very moving! I will definitely check out Amalia Rodriguez’ music. Thanks for the recommendation !!

0 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 7, 2024, 7:05 AMpositive64%

This was a rare case of me figuring out a theme on my own, so a nice surprise. That being said... Yesterday we had CZARISTS and today a TSAR. Are the editors trolling us on purpose?

16 recommendations5 replies
MikeCanadaApr 7, 2024, 2:08 PMnegative70%

@Andrzej I never could understand the Tsar spelling. The name is a diminutive of caesar so it should be spelled with a C, in my reckoning. But I agree, the most common Xword spelling seems to be tsar so this was a bit of trap.

0 recommendations
EdHalifax, Nova ScotiaApr 7, 2024, 2:26 PMneutral76%

@Andrzej I think it's fair to allow any spelling variation of any word that can be found in a good dictionary. I'm OK with either tsar or czar -- just as long as they don't use both of them in the same puzzle.

3 recommendations
Helen WrightNow In Somerset UKApr 7, 2024, 11:09 AMpositive85%

Yay, a doable Sunday. For reasons too boring to relate, my brain is a little overwhelmed right now, so getting the theme early on felt like a win. Like Caitlin it was the BLACK EYED PS that pinged the lightbulb. Working out the others was a lot of fun. Yes, it was as crunchy as I’d expect for a Sunday, but knowing the theme was such a help. As always, the many US centric names and products were the sticking point, but the crosses gave me enough for an educated guess most of the time. I stuck with Casey, as in Casey Jones, at 96A for too long. I remembered the tv show from childhood, perhaps it had started on radio?🤷‍♀️ As 72D and 99 D were complete naticks it was a good a guess as any. Ditto 123A. I had ‘lit a fire’; it’s a no-no here, other than in designated fire pits. The one clunky sounding clue to my English ears was CIDERY. Is that genuinely what they’re called in the US? Here in Somerset, the home of cider production in the UK, they’re called cider barns, or just fruit farms. I’m lucky enough to live in the middle of a large apple and pear orchard. In the next month (if the storm winds ease off) we’ll be surrounded by blossom. It’s an incredibly beautiful sight. Crossword complete, the dog and I are off for a blowy, muddy walk around said orchards. Current wind speeds are around 45 mph, enough to whip your raincoat about. Ugh.

16 recommendations8 replies
Pani KorunovaPortugalApr 7, 2024, 11:11 AMneutral67%

@Helen Wright do you call your raincoat a Mac? Inquiring minds want to know 😄😄

3 recommendations
MWPhiladelphiaApr 7, 2024, 12:10 PMneutral73%

@Pani Korunova Yes, Mac is short for Macintosh, meaning raincoat, in the UK.

4 recommendations
TreegardenStamford, CTApr 7, 2024, 1:41 PMneutral56%

@MW “And the banker never wears a Mac In the pouring rain Very strange Penny Lane…”

9 recommendations
Bonnie AnnGeorgetown, TXApr 7, 2024, 8:40 PMpositive97%

Thank you Tracy Gray for double the fun puzzle. I really enjoyed all the clues and solves, specially the Blackeyed PP's. I had a few look ups, I don't know sports folks names, but the rest just flowed. I had every letter except the "r" in tabouret/Ensor not knowing either one. The double y in the southeast corner was another fun one. After yesterday's extremely difficult puzzle (I was determined to finish and think I had to look up every other word...geez laweez someone is very smart and it's not me. Hopefully I'll retain some of what I learned for next time). Thanks again NYTs and cheering on Mr. Shortz in his recovery! Tomorrow is the big solar event here, so lots of extra excitement afoot. Have a great day all.

16 recommendations
AlisonNova ScotiaApr 7, 2024, 2:38 AMpositive97%

What a fun puzzle! We nailed it in a bit over 45 minutes. Nice rebus action, and some good puns. I chuckled at the inclusion of Taylor Swift, Black-eyed Peas, and Encanto all in one puzzle – bit of recent pop hit history. Hope Mr. Shortz is recovering well. Yes, I notice a difference. No, it's not the end of the world, nor of my subscription :-)

15 recommendations
CaptainQuahogPlanet EarthApr 7, 2024, 4:07 PMnegative85%

It took me most of the morning to recover from 28A... I just don't know why CLAMicide is OK in these puzzles. Other than that -- a good puzzle, and a very easy theme that should keep some of the whining about rebuses down. Very approachable.

15 recommendations2 replies
Jill from BrooklynThe InterwebsApr 7, 2024, 4:12 PMnegative66%

@CaptainQuahog Did a clam write this comment?

2 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 6, 2024, 10:23 PMneutral68%

SEACREST Saturday; KASEM Sunday. CZARISTS Saturday; TSAR Nicholas Sunday. Saturday, a lot of complaints about the puzzle's difficulty; Sunday, no doubt there will be complaints about rebuses. This one took me half the time that the Saturday one did, and I hardly had to slow down anywhere. You CAN have, and you CAN enjoy, harder and easier puzzles.

14 recommendations2 replies
KeanaLos AngelesApr 6, 2024, 11:10 PMpositive97%

@Steve L Saturday's was very hard, and I loved it!

8 recommendations
Al in PittsburghPittsburgh, PAApr 7, 2024, 5:00 AMneutral52%

@Steve L Same here. Half the time of Saturday's which required the "sleep on it" method to find a breakthrough. Today rated a "bogey" on my personal Sunday scale.

5 recommendations
ClemNashvilleApr 6, 2024, 11:58 PMneutral54%

Quelle surprise! CABOOSE - again! I’m not even going to go through it again: it’s so clear that these puzzles are NOT submitted by different people around the country and edited for months and … odd words keep popping up on consecutive days and then disappearing again for years. It’s a sweet facade … but I’ve grown rather fond of the idea of the one guy who writes them all and gets paid daily in cash (and retreats to his favorite watering hole with his three best friends JB, JD, and sweet GR, etc.) [See my previous comments on the subject.] Never forget ARHAT. Pull my other leg, NYT! LOL

14 recommendations6 replies
EricLos AngelesApr 7, 2024, 12:21 AMneutral49%

@Clem I've been working through some old puzzles and recently came across some variation of CABOOSE and was surprised it doesn't pop up more often

3 recommendations
Whoa NellieOut WestApr 7, 2024, 3:01 AMneutral72%

@Clem Caboose. The clue that never ends.

4 recommendations
Man and 2 dogsVermontApr 7, 2024, 1:23 PMpositive92%

Great Sunday puzzle — the theme was very nicely executed and satisfying to uncover, but also pretty easy to pick up on (though IMO it would have worked just as well sans rebus). I felt a bit Naticked in the NE corner at Puente and Ensor — and this was compounded by the dictionary trivia “tabouret”, which makes me wish some crossword influencer would use their platform to coin a new term for such a Natick subtype. That said, neither Puente nor Ensor seems obscure, so I don’t think this was a proper Natick…just an attack on me, personally. I’m also tempted to nitpick about “CINC”, as I’ve only seen “CIC” used *within* the military. But maybe that’s just me? Anyway: that was a great weekend pairing, kudos to everyone involved!

14 recommendations6 replies
Barry AnconaNew York NYApr 7, 2024, 1:30 PMnegative54%

"That said, neither Puente nor Ensor seems obscure, so I don’t think this was a proper Natick…just an attack on me, personally." Man and 2 dogs, Bravo! Bravo! ...................................

16 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiApr 7, 2024, 2:42 PMneutral57%

@Man and 2 dogs Yep, it's just you. (Ha ha, scroll to my post for another viewpoint from an Army kid.)

5 recommendations
dvdmgsrState College, PAApr 8, 2024, 12:51 AMneutral73%

Is there a way for me to put a hold on my streak until Will Shortz comes back? I don’t mind hard puzzles, when they’re fun. I think it might be better for me to just move to a different puzzle universe.

14 recommendations
John DealGoffstown NHApr 7, 2024, 2:46 AMnegative78%

Ugh. I finished with no hints or lookups, but gods above was this a viciously Natick-y puzzle. I sussed out the gimmick right away and blitzed through the vast majority of the grid, but at the end I had to waste a whole lot of minutes playing the plug-in-arbitrary-letters game in a few spots in order to get the win. I'm not complaining that there were answers I didn't know in this grid, but some of the crosses were needlessly, nastily obscure. Just glad I'm done and can move on to more enjoyable puzzles.

13 recommendations2 replies
SteveLondonApr 7, 2024, 7:04 AMpositive79%

@John Deal I've seen in past comments on here that success is what you define it as, so how about changing yours to "I don't do lookups unless the trivia is needlessly and nastily obscure" and you'll be full of the joys of Spring (again)

3 recommendations
TeresaBerlinApr 7, 2024, 9:18 AMneutral36%

@John Deal: Agreed! It was overall easy to the point of boring (speaking only for myself here, others please don't pounce) and I liked the gimmick well enough, but it was unforgivably full of Naticks.

0 recommendations
NancyNYCApr 7, 2024, 12:40 PMpositive79%

Liked this one a lot! If I had gone to see "The Wiz" even once like everyone else has, I would have been able to make I'VE EATEN fit at 1D from the get-go. But I never could stand all that shrill caterwauling from the woman with the green face. So I didn't know EE ON DOWN THE ROAD. What made it even harder to see was that I had "THE ROAr", not "THE ROAD". SErenE instead of SEDATE for "Calm" -- and I wouldn't give it up. I had less trouble not knowing ANTIHERO -- which came in on its own. I don't listen to Taylor Swift either -- can't stand all that endless caterwauling about her relationships-gone-bad. And even though I've never heard of, much less listened to the BLACKEYED PP, I have heard of a TEACUP POODLE. I'm pretty sure that's where I picked up the theme. By then ??ITORLOSEIT was already filled in and everything fell into place. Very enjoyable -- with wonderfully well-chosen theme answers at both the Acrosses and the Downs. I always love it when the Acrosses and Downs play differently in a rebus puzzle. Gives it a special je ne said quoi. Great job, Tracy!

13 recommendations6 replies
NancyNYCApr 7, 2024, 1:02 PMneutral46%

Did most of it yesterday -- so I forgot that I inadvertently cheated on the backless stool. I had SERENE, remember, for "Calm" -- giving me nABOURET for the stool. NABOURET??? Really??? I fed NABOURET into Google. Google sniffed dismissively and sent me back TABOURET. I looked up TABOURET and it was...wait for it!...a stool! This enabled me to change SERENE to SEDATE. So, I'm not sure I would have been able to finish this without the help from Google. But as God is my witness, I didn't intend to cheat!

1 recommendations
Retired personSouth Bend, IndianaApr 7, 2024, 3:04 PMnegative51%

@Nancy I think you’re thinking of “Wicked” rather than “The Wiz,” for the green-faced woman.

2 recommendations
NESB is Still thinkingGreat LakesApr 8, 2024, 2:01 AMpositive79%

Today was my first time figuring out a rebus without help. And I figured out all of them. Back on March 18, I commented that I was considering giving up on crosswords to concentrate on painting portraits: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/3tpr74?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share" target="_blank">https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/3tpr74?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share</a> But Eric Hougland of Austin TX gave me the exact encouragement I needed here in a comment when I needed it: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/3tq13h?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share" target="_blank">https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/3tq13h?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share</a> And I'm almost finished with a complex double portrait watercolor commission too. -`♡´-

13 recommendations2 replies
HeathieJSt PaulApr 8, 2024, 2:28 AMpositive98%

@NESB is Still thinking Congratulations all around! That's awesome! Eric is terrific with encouraging other solvers and providing always helpful and kind support!! 😊

6 recommendations
GBKApr 8, 2024, 2:35 PMpositive92%

@NESB is Still thinking I remember that thread (and looking back from your link, see I "upvoted" your final reply). I'm so glad you circled back about that! Congratulations on your getting all the rebi(?) on Sunday's puzzle!!! 🙌💪🤸‍♀️ And on the watercolor portrait!! When you said you're better at painting, you weren't joking! 🙌🎨✨

2 recommendations
Liz BDurham, NCApr 6, 2024, 10:28 PMnegative54%

Easy and breezy and fun. Until I ended with an error. Was it the way I entered the double letters? No, I had an extraneous L in LITTERED. Oops. And today I learned about a TABOURET.

12 recommendations
DeckerWashington DCApr 7, 2024, 12:48 AMpositive99%

Finally a rebus I can solve! :D Really enjoyed today’s puzzle!

12 recommendations
PCSLCApr 7, 2024, 12:53 AMpositive90%

This was a fun puzzle. I enjoy rebuses when they accompany a theme, and these worked really well. I figured there had to be some sort of trick when “black eyed peas” didn’t fit, and I got “seize” the moment from crosses so it all clicked into place rather nicely. That said, certain number of the non-theme clues, like the past couple weeks, seem to really lack the wit, elegance, and tautness that I associate with the Shortz era. I don’t know that it’s made them that much more difficult, on the whole, but they have been notably less fun for me. I know Mr. Shortz’s time as editor is finite, and I wonder if we will see his like again on the NYT crossword. I hope he is recovering well (not for the sake of the crossword, just for him as a human being).

12 recommendations
AsherBrooklynApr 7, 2024, 12:55 AMpositive98%

I enjoyed this puzzle. It was plenty hard but fun, which is what counts for me. The rebuses were extremely clever.

12 recommendations
Marshall WalthewArdmoreApr 7, 2024, 3:40 AMpositive88%

What a contrast with yesterday’s puzzle. Saturday I had perhaps my slowest time ever (and that despite a couple look ups). Sunday I had one of my fastest Sunday times ever. I liked the double letter trick, and enjoyed much of the rest of the Sunday puzzle, especially hip place for a drink as a clue for FLASK. Now if only Saturday had been a smidge less opaque and Sunday a little more challenging, I’d have doubled my pleasure. Why oh why don’t these constructors calibrate their puzzles to my particular solving level?

12 recommendations
Times RitaNVApr 7, 2024, 1:58 PMpositive86%

Finally, a puzzle I could sink my teeth into, finish, and enjoy. As a veteran solver, I've been so distressed by the horrible turn the end-of-week puzzles have taken, so this was a breath of fresh air. Thank you, Tracy!

12 recommendations
HeathieJSt PaulApr 7, 2024, 5:24 PMpositive93%

I wanted Casey Kasem yesterday but I got him today!! Yeah!! I said it yesterday and I'll say it again, keep your feet on the ground and keep reaching for the (crossword) stars! I guess to give you some insight into my life, the only words I could come up with to go with joint (word with joint or jam) in the midwest, was either gin or pain. 🫣 Neither of those went with jam, for which I could only think at the moment of Julia Andrews beautifully singing "Ti, a drink with jam and bread.... " So, all in all, it was a fun experience even my brief and silly lapses. Very fun puzzle and a cute theme! I figured it out with BLACK EYED PP. I sailed pretty well through without any lookups or helps in about 2/3 of my average time. Had one error at the end because I didn't know either the ENSOR or TABOURET... I figured all the rest out from the crosses but where the two of them crossed I plopped in an L and thought that sounded okay. I kind of figured that was my error when I didn't get the happy music, so I tried an R. Huzzah!! Thanks for a fun Sunday puzzle!!

12 recommendations7 replies
GBKApr 7, 2024, 6:37 PMpositive94%

@HeathieJ It was great getting Casey Kasem in the grid today! I have to say, I did impress myself yesterday, plunking in SEACREST after only a moment's pause in which to note the O. G. Top 40 host wouldn't fit any which way. IIRC, it was about the *only* answer I got on my first (second, third...) pass. Oof! And now I have Dame Andrews in my head! I'd probably prefer the Blackeyed Peas, but the Sound of Music is a sweet memory, too: We had the cast album, and my sister and I played it almost as much as the Mary Poppins one when we were kids. (But Camelot was the fave. Loved me a tragic ending even at a young age-!) FWIW, my bread and jam reference is always "Jam for Frances". Very relatable when I was a kid!

2 recommendations
MAR1VA, USAApr 7, 2024, 6:50 PMneutral43%

@HeathieJ I owe you thanks! If it weren't for your comment yesterday, I wouldn't have gotten KASEM so quickly today, or I would undoubtedly have spelled it wrong. @G And I owe you thanks for reminding me of Bread and Jam for Frances, a childhood favorite of mine as well! badger, badger, emu

3 recommendations
MmmmHmmmMcLean, VAApr 7, 2024, 10:07 PMneutral59%

Looking at several editorial oddities, I think you all miss Will Shortz

12 recommendations
JayTeeKissimmeeApr 7, 2024, 2:55 AMpositive88%

After the difficulty with Saturday's, this one was a relief. Discovered the rebus with the BLACK EYED PP answer, and that also helped with the tiny dog answer. Some of the other theme answers dropped in immediately because of the rebuses, which sped the solve along immensely. I lucked out with my guess for 17D/35A, and did think that was a bit difficult for a Sunday, but you're bound to run into a few things you don't know in a puzzle like this. I did pick up some trivia that surprised me, in that the Santana hit "Oye Como Va" was a cover of a composition by the 'King of Timbales', Tito PUENTE. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BpAXzTpANNw" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BpAXzTpANNw</a> Nice puzzle, Tracy, and thanks!

11 recommendations1 replies
Bob T.New York, NYApr 7, 2024, 6:09 PMpositive92%

@JayTee Thanks for posting; I'm familiar with Santana's version (and posted it elsewhere) but nice to hear the original.

1 recommendations