Wednesday, April 30, 2025

195
Comments
0.303
Avg Sentiment
75
Positive
90
Neutral
30
Negative
Sort by:
LewisAsheville, NCApr 30, 2025, 11:11 AMneutral70%

I would like the brand for the HAND SOAP and FACE WASH to be Dial. Et tu, emu.

108 recommendations5 replies
Sam CorbinNew York, NYApr 30, 2025, 11:35 AMpositive51%

@Lewis !!!

10 recommendations
JustinMinnesotaApr 30, 2025, 1:10 PMneutral77%

@Lewis Yeah, but to clean the inside you'd need Irish Spring.

38 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiApr 30, 2025, 1:17 PMnegative71%

@Lewis That would be a Missed Opportunity, but maybe another time, eh, Adam? (BTW, Dial soap turned out to be an allergen for me..."allergic contact dermatitis" made my teens miserable until I left for college; there was no other soap in our house. 'Deodorant soaps' are often a problem. My Tip for the Day)

7 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYApr 30, 2025, 1:45 PMpositive96%

@Lewis This is sufficient proof that you need to be on the puzzle editorial board. This would have been a brilliant addition to today's puzzle!

10 recommendations
Lady Morgan Kelly DianaLawrence, NJ USAApr 30, 2025, 8:11 PMpositive73%

@Lewis I’m more of an unscented Aveeno body wash with essential oils (DIY soaps) woman lol! Namaste!!

1 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 30, 2025, 2:12 AMpositive87%

Sam writes: It’s not the past that’s loved but the love that’s past. That might be the best sentence I’ve read in Wordplay in a…um…long time.

71 recommendations12 replies
Niki BBoston, MAApr 30, 2025, 3:04 AMpositive77%

@Steve L I breezed right past it... so thank you for pointing it out. And I agree.

7 recommendations
BethGreenbeltApr 30, 2025, 4:05 AMpositive90%

@Steve L Thank you for pointing this out. I too missed it as I was skimming the article. It's lovely.

5 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 30, 2025, 4:24 AMneutral51%

@Steve L It's not the L that's Steved, it's the Steve that's L'ed.

16 recommendations
JustinMinnesotaApr 30, 2025, 1:18 PMneutral61%

@Steve L So do you think this that what the picture for this column is referring to? That picture is a more difficult reference for me to figure out than the clock puns (which I didn't get until the puzzle was finished...nicely done.)

1 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYApr 30, 2025, 1:54 PMneutral59%

@Steve L You're right to point out the poignancy of this seemingly off-handed remark. See my comment for a deeper dive into the remark and its connection to the photo.

1 recommendations
Eric HouglandDurango COApr 30, 2025, 3:49 PMneutral44%

@Steve L Thanks for calling this to our attention. As I usually do, I skimmed the column, and I missed that nice bit of wordplay.

2 recommendations
EddieKentuckyApr 30, 2025, 2:17 AMneutral67%

I done did this puzz

58 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 30, 2025, 4:03 AMnegative44%

I thought maybe taking a week off would be enough to restore my enjoyment of NYT grids. Well, apparently it was not. I don't get the theme, TBH. I mean, I *get* it but I don't understand what's special or particularly witty about it. I suppose it's... Punny? In this dad-joke sort of really unfunny way Mr Shortz seems to love so much? Meh. Anyway, I'm off to wash my clocks with hand soap Ha Ha, so funny 🫤 Of all the trivia and names I knew... The Afghan president 🤣 Spring is in full swing in Warsaw. Even the oaks are sprouting leaves. They are always one of the last trees to do so around here - before climate change wreaked havoc on nature, when winters were colder and longer, oak trees would not begin to become green before May. And chestnuts are in bloom - another sign of high spring. For decades the exam at the end of high school - "matura" (or "egzamin dojrzałości", maturity exam) - was organized over a few days at the beginning of May, just as the chestnuts were blooming: and it was a hard exam, so teenagers were stressed out by the sight of those otherwise beautiful flowers. My matura in the late 90s was one of the last on this traditional schedule. Then educational reform changed the exam timetable and contents, and the chestnuts started blooming in April. I may only be in my 40s, but I'm beginning to see how people may miss "the good old days" 🤣 Signing off for a few days/weeks again.

56 recommendations9 replies
SebastianLondonApr 30, 2025, 4:22 AMpositive94%

@Andrzej Have a restful detox and hope you come back refreshed!

22 recommendations
Hobby GardenerGermanyApr 30, 2025, 5:55 AMnegative41%

@Andrzej Sorry to hear that! I’m surely not the only one who will miss your contributions to the comments.

25 recommendations
KristinSan FranciscoApr 30, 2025, 6:10 AMpositive94%

@Andrzej I took 2 months off and found renewed enjoyment upon my return (and the comments section seemed less acerbic as well)!

8 recommendations
Liz SingerParisApr 30, 2025, 8:45 AMpositive93%

@Andrzej Sorry you are signing off again, I enjoy reading your comments and thoughts! Enjoy your Spring break.

6 recommendations
ByronTorontoApr 30, 2025, 9:42 AMnegative63%

@Andrzej Seeing the impacts of climate change within the span of just our lifetimes is enough to drag anybody down. Same with just about everything else in the world. I find the Russian barbarity in Ukraine to be horrifying from my distant vantage point, I can’t imagine what it’s like having it happen on your doorstep. For what it’s worth, I find the crossword to be a very pleasant diversion from the troubles of the world. Sometimes my dark mood bleeds into my crossword world but for the most part it’s a looked-forward-to respite and brief bit of asylum. Your recollection of blooming “kashtan” (Ukrainian for chestnut, not sure what it is in Polish) brought me back to my year in Ukraine in ‘89. It was pretty dreary and grey back then but spring was beautiful. I remember walking with friends around the Podil with its art shops down cobblestone streets and the Pechersk Lavra at the top of the hill. A breath of fresh air after a bleak Soviet winter! Which is to say that hope springs eternal.

19 recommendations
dutchirisberkeleyApr 30, 2025, 11:11 PMneutral58%

@Andrzej The chestnut trees that line our street are in bloom too, as well as the giant antique rhododendron, camellia, mock orange, roses, mammoth geranium and calla lilies in our yard. The wall of trumpet vine has buds and the Dutch irises are waist high, but neither is yet in bloom. It has been sunny and warm for the past few days, but we are promised more cold weather on Friday. I stay bundled up in my ratty down vest and hoodie, and that's inside the house. Coastal weather can be a trial, but we are not really suffering. Our house is still standing, buildings are not in ruins, and no terrifying air raid sirens—so far—but we have no idea what is going to happen from one day to the next. Everything is in turmoil and ruled by whims.

4 recommendations
MikeMunsterApr 30, 2025, 3:21 AMpositive89%

The watchmaker-turned-comedian had great timing. (His set was the clock of the town.)

43 recommendations4 replies
LeanneNormal, ILApr 30, 2025, 3:33 AMneutral45%

@Mike For a second there you had me going, but I caught on after a minute. I've got to hand it to you, Mike.

25 recommendations
HeidiDallasApr 30, 2025, 3:43 AMnegative76%

@Mike Just chiming in to say that sounds a little cuckoo.

5 recommendations
dutchirisberkeleyApr 30, 2025, 5:13 AMneutral48%

@Mike Complaint about a cheesy watch? The time is ripe.

13 recommendations
jmaeagle, wiApr 30, 2025, 2:45 PMneutral40%

@Mike I guess you'll do anything for the seiko a good pun. At least it's better than some of your math ones which are horror -- logical!

5 recommendations
JamieUSAApr 30, 2025, 2:45 AMpositive95%

The theme was kind of flimsy, but I really liked the fill. Even the three-letter entries were fresh. I also finished up a month of gold stars so… go me.

34 recommendations1 replies
Elizabeth ConnorsChicagoApr 30, 2025, 3:48 AMpositive96%

@Jamie Yay you!

2 recommendations
LewisAsheville, NCApr 30, 2025, 11:56 AMpositive88%

Oh, fresh punny theme, perfect for basing a puzzle on, cleaning that clock with HAND SOAP and FACE WASH. Hah! Throw in DAWDLE, which looks and sounds marvelous to me, and which reminds me of my mom, who I miss, and who used the word all the time. Add a bit of irony – having CENSOR BAR in the grid, as puzzles almost always have them – horizontal lines of black squares – but there’s nary a one today. Cross RIPE with ARID (sounds like the deodorant brand), put a backward SELAD in the same row as SALAD, and toss in RESCUE DOG, which describes three of the most scintillating beings I’ve ever known. And you’ve easily won me over, Adam, with your STEW, your HASH, of loveliness. Grateful thumbs up here!

31 recommendations
LauraRhode IslandApr 30, 2025, 2:29 AMneutral53%

Feels like Tuesday and Wednesday could have been switched this week.

24 recommendations1 replies
MeganAurora, COApr 30, 2025, 2:42 AMneutral63%

@Laura was thinking the same thing

5 recommendations
SebastianLondonApr 30, 2025, 4:25 AMpositive36%

Never before have I heard of the phrase, CLEANONESCLOCK and now that I have, I reckon I'll promptly eject it from my memory 😬😆

23 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYApr 30, 2025, 12:59 PMpositive80%

Today's photo that accompanies the "Wordplay" column is touching and nostalgic, demonstrating both "the past that’s loved" and "the love that’s past." It's a photo taken from an auction of Beatle's memorabilia. It's a note from George Harrison to his first wife Pattie Boyd, stating "Pattie, don't forget I love you -- George" Many of us know the story of what happened next: a marriage destroyed by infidelity and drug use. The dark side of wealth and fame that came early and suddenly. And Pattie's relationship with Eric Clapton, that gave us the song "Layla." And George and Eric remained friends. Nostalgia and romanticism, concealed below the jokey "Heart Test" headline. Beautifully done, Sam!

23 recommendations2 replies
The X-PhileLexington, KYApr 30, 2025, 1:33 PMpositive85%

Seeing how brilliant today's photo was, I need an explanation of yesterday's. For those who don't remember, it showed a picture from the early '70s of British actress Judy Huxtable using her then-boyfriend Peter Cook (one-time comedic partner of Dudley Moore) as a bridge to cross a creek. The title of the column was "Lofty Tributary", a small change on one of the clues ("Lofty tribute" for ODE). My best guess is that Moore was being a GENT by keeping his girlfriend dry, holding her a-"loft" as she crossed this "tributary" of a river. Yes, I know, I'm thinking about this too much. But sometimes, like today, there's a payoff. @Sam Corbin, can you help me out?

9 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYApr 30, 2025, 1:42 PMneutral63%

And the outstretched hands that say, not "Here for your perusal and purchase,...", but "Here is my love that I offer to you. Will you take it???" And the gloves that say, not "I must protect this valuable piece of paper from my hand oils", but "I'm afraid that I might get burnt..." Oh, Sam, you're killing me!

8 recommendations
Niki BBoston, MAApr 30, 2025, 2:10 PMpositive96%

@hardroch you wanted me to let you know about my Town election race ... I lost but it was super close (3600 votes to 3296). I'm actually quite delighted with the support I received given that my opponent is well known in town and a long time incumbent. Not quite CLEANINGONESCLOCK!! My campaign was very modest in term of my outreach and given the closeness of the race I will definitely run next year. Super super interesting to run for local office. I suggest all you smart contributors to this board consider it in your own cities and towns. Good news is that several candidates I supported won, and it's enough to potentially make a huge difference in some aspects of my town (Milton MA). As for the puzzle, it was fun and quick and I love a dad joke or three so right up my alley. I completed it very late last night as I watched the election results roll in. Cheers to all!

19 recommendations2 replies
John CarsonJersey CoastApr 30, 2025, 2:29 PMpositive97%

@Niki B Congratulations on coming so close and best of luck in your next campaign.

11 recommendations
JoshPittsburghApr 30, 2025, 1:56 PMneutral90%

TIL (I think) that when clued as valleys, even broad ones, the etymologically distinct vALES and DALES present a Loa/Kea situation.

17 recommendations
HeidiDallasApr 30, 2025, 4:06 AMneutral57%

It would be HARD to DISCO dance with PEG LEGS. I’m sure someone could COACH you through it, though. Perhaps an OLD FLAME? (Better bring your EKG.) Seeing CENSOR BAR in the middle of the puzzle gave me a theme idea. You know how there are certain words that are allowed in the puzzle but we’re not permitted to use them in our comments? I’m envisioning a puzzle where these are the theme words, and they’re all hidden under the black squares. Under black censor bars, so to speak. If I knew how to construct a puzzle, I’d make this happen!

15 recommendations3 replies
LarsLondonApr 30, 2025, 7:51 AMneutral67%

@Heidi ⬛⬛⬛⬛'⬛ ⬛ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛ ⬛⬛⬛⬛!

8 recommendations
ByronTorontoApr 30, 2025, 9:32 AMneutral50%

@Heidi It would be hard to enter the answers in the print edition!

3 recommendations
Rich in AtlantaAustell, GeorgiaApr 30, 2025, 11:26 AMneutral55%

Well, kind of a tough Tuesday for me, but managed to work it out. And... must admit that I remained appropriately 'puzzled' to some extent about the theme even after I finished. That's all on me - no big deal. Answer history search today was inspired by SPEEDO. Wondered about a different kind of clue for that and... wondered if MREARL (or MISTEREARL) had ever been in a puzzle. And... Nope and nope. Wonder how many will get that connection. And of course my puzzle find today. A Monday from August 2, 2010 by Diane Baker Van Hoff. Three theme clues in that one, here are those clues and answers: "Tempo?" THESPEEDOFMUSIC "Ka-ching?" THESOUNDOFMONEY "Spectrum?" THECOLOROFLIGHT Thought that was pretty clever. Here's the Xword Info link: <a href="https://www.xwordinfo.com/Crossword?date=8/2/2010&g=17&d=A" target="_blank">https://www.xwordinfo.com/Crossword?date=8/2/2010&g=17&d=A</a> I'll shut up now. ...

15 recommendations3 replies
Chris in AusMelbourneApr 30, 2025, 11:57 AMneutral64%

@Rich in Atlanta - It’s a Wednesday (so probably why it’s a little tricker than you expected!)

5 recommendations
LewisAsheville, NCApr 30, 2025, 12:51 PMpositive98%

@Rich in Atlanta -- Wow, that is a clever theme; thanks for finding it and posting it!

3 recommendations
PaulScotlandApr 30, 2025, 2:41 PMnegative82%

I was really baffled by 31 down , then realised the clue was “Stitchers gathering” and not “Snitchers gathering “ Dyslexics of the world Untie!

15 recommendations1 replies
michalightningAustin, TXMay 1, 2025, 12:57 AMneutral54%

@Paul I read it as "Pitchers" some how and even came up with "a swinglers" initially. Yikes 😂

1 recommendations
Steven M.New York, NYApr 30, 2025, 2:11 AMpositive98%

Best month I've ever had with only two blue stars

12 recommendations2 replies
Dave K.New York, NYApr 30, 2025, 2:46 AMneutral63%

@Steven M. I had 4, two of them Sundays (oh the horror).

4 recommendations
John PeilSan AntonioApr 30, 2025, 1:03 PMnegative86%

@Steven M. Same here, a Friday and a Saturday. March was . . . much worse

1 recommendations
BethGreenbeltApr 30, 2025, 4:28 AMpositive55%

Well, that puzzle pretty much solved itself, which was nice because I have a headache and probably should have waited until the morning. I didn't fully understand the theme until I read the column... I mean, I am familiar with the expression CLEAN ONE'S CLOCK and figured out what THE TIME IS RIPE had to do with it, but the connection to HAND SOAP and FACE WASH only appeared to be related to general cleaning until Sam pointed out the reference to clock hands and faces. Are SPEEDO swimsuits more form-fitting than other brands? Favorite clue: Like a 1,000-piece monochromatic jigsaw puzzle. Reminded me of a puzzle our family worked on for a week. It was a giant red (so much red!) Coke can, and I think it was 5,000 pieces.

12 recommendations5 replies
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 30, 2025, 5:08 AMneutral59%

@Beth Speedos sure are form-fitting, aren't they?

7 recommendations
NoemiQueens, NYApr 30, 2025, 10:17 AMneutral63%

@Beth The key is to think of men’s swimsuits. You’re perfectly right that their women’s suits are no more form-fitting than any other brand.

6 recommendations
Helen WrightNow In Somerset UKApr 30, 2025, 1:00 PMneutral60%

Straightforward despite not ever having heard the theme before. I think I understand now from reading the comments that it generally means to trounce someone? But clearly it works as a washing metaphor as well. Ok, I’ll go with it. Chuckled at KALE facing FATS. The former is Beelzebub’s salad, the latter nectar of the gods, liberally used in my Carnivore lifestyle. Yum. Love the clue for PEGLEGS. Aar. Having the Alpacas’ fibre checked today for quality pre-shearing. Not looking to make money out of my girls, but a few skeins of yarn for knitting socks would be nice. Otherwise we’re self sufficient in garden fibre; it makes excellent slug deterrent.

12 recommendations1 replies
Caroline KearneyBrooklyn, NYApr 30, 2025, 10:11 PMpositive78%

@Helen Wright Even though we are about 80% vegetarians, I agree with you about kale and love few things more than potatoes roasted in duck fat.

2 recommendations
MomerlynPAApr 30, 2025, 3:14 PMneutral74%

Today's ear worm: My Grandfather's Clock. My grandfather's clock was too large for the shelf, So it stood ninety years on the floor. It was taller by half than the old man himself, Though it weighed not a pennyweight more. It was bought on the morn of the day that he was born, And was always his treasure and pride. But it stopped short, Never to go again, When the old man died. Chorus: Ninety years without slumbering, Tick, tock, tick, tock. His life seconds numbering, Tick, tock, tick. It stopped short, never to go again, When the old man died. In watching its pendulum Swing to and fro, Many hours had he spent as a boy; And in childhood and manhood the clock seemed to know, And to share both his grief and his joy. For it struck twenty-four when he entered at the door, With a blooming and beautiful bride. But it stopped short, never to go again, When the old man died. There's more, of course, but it won't fit here. I loved this puzzle. What a fun Wednesday! I usually find Wednesdays have a small level of frustration, but this one had more fun than not, so thank you for starting my day with fun!

12 recommendations3 replies
Times RitaNVApr 30, 2025, 3:38 PMpositive97%

@Momerlyn And now it's my ear worm, and much more fun than this puzzle. Thanks for the trip down memory lane!

4 recommendations
BethGreenbeltApr 30, 2025, 4:11 PMpositive96%

@Momerlyn I remember singing this in elementary school. Thank you!

3 recommendations
kilaueabartOakland CAApr 30, 2025, 4:36 PMneutral77%

@Momerlyn I could have recited the first verse and chorus without peeking, but the second verse was quite unfamiliar. I wonder how many years it has been. 70? 80?

6 recommendations
StrikerShawnApr 30, 2025, 2:46 AMnegative76%

I found the two “bottleful” clues oddly annoying. Not sure why they stuck out to me enough to comment. I think it was the / . And the word “bottleful” was just kinda unnecessary. I enjoyed the punny fill for those two clues, however. And I enjoyed the puzzle quite a bit. Perhaps a skosh too easy, but most puzzles CLEAN my CLOCK so I shall not complain about a breezy solve.

11 recommendations1 replies
CindyIndianapolisApr 30, 2025, 6:21 PMneutral49%

@Striker Why aren't they written the same?!?!

0 recommendations
StephenSan FranciscoApr 30, 2025, 3:53 AMneutral45%

As someone who has somehow never heard the idiom “clean one’s clock”, this theme didn’t have much by away of “aha!” moments for me. But assuming I’m the weird one and this is a real idiom (it wouldn’t be the first time!) I do feel like the constructor did a good job with its multiple meanings. Nice, breezy solve.

11 recommendations4 replies
sotto vocepnwApr 30, 2025, 4:01 AMnegative67%

@Stephen If you're weird, I'm weird alongside you. I also didn't know the expression; never heard it in my whole life.🤷

6 recommendations
Al in PittsburghCairo,NYApr 30, 2025, 4:31 AMneutral84%

@Stephen Alex Trebek was once asked if, with all his experience as host of Jeopardy, he could compete with current contestants. As I remember it, his answer was something like: "I could hold my own with people my age but the younger ones would clean my clock." Why I remember this after many years is a mystery.

29 recommendations
FrancineIsraelApr 30, 2025, 12:53 PMneutral69%

@Stephen Interesting origin of the idiom: <a href="https://grammarist.com/idiom/clean-someones-clock" target="_blank">https://grammarist.com/idiom/clean-someones-clock</a>/

3 recommendations
CindyIndianapolisApr 30, 2025, 6:27 PMpositive50%

@Francine Interesting that "beat hands down" is listed as the first alternative. 😉

1 recommendations
JoelLondonApr 30, 2025, 8:51 AMneutral41%

I didn't think it was super challenging, solved in under 10 mins and thought the theme was ok but not hugely compelling - certainly a bit different and unique. I did enjoy quite a lot of the clues, on their own I wouldn't have been able to solve a few but was able to with crossings

10 recommendations1 replies
TejasLondonApr 30, 2025, 9:24 AMneutral89%

@Joel I'm curious, exactly how much under ten minutes was your solve?

2 recommendations
CCNYNYApr 30, 2025, 10:45 AMpositive95%

Fun one. Not sure why, but I really love seeing left-right symmetry when I open the grid. Probably because it means there’s something charming afoot, and the rotational had to be tossed to let it shine! Thank you Adam! Happy hump day all!

10 recommendations
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNApr 30, 2025, 7:29 PMpositive93%

To not let the perfect be the enemy of the good is a great all around life lesson that I often remind myself to heed. Appreciated reading it in constructor's notes. Well, it may not have been a perfect puzzle but to me it was a good one! I had fun filling it out, I learned things (KATANA and ASHRAF), and had some chuckles ("Ways of the world" for ROADS, "Silly ones" for GEESE, and "Chance to see the big game" for SAFARI.) I first put STEW in at 65A instead of HASH. Was amused to later put STEW in at its proper place at 50D. Fun fact: if you were to go to a diner with my family of origin, including niblings and spouses, every one of us (except my husband) will order corned beef HASH, two eggs over-medium, and extra crispy hashbrowns. My siblings and I all married up but there are some raised eyebrows when my husband is the only one to go with steak & eggs or some such. Guess I have a thing for a handsome rebel! Lots of food references: HASH, STEW, SALAD, KALE, HOCK, FATS, GEESE... did I go too far? Good thing I had a bagel sandwich while solving to stave off hunger. Wonder if there's ever been a theme around cooking one's goose or your goose is cooked.   So, I know KALE has a bad rap, but we love it and grow it on our garden balcony. Here's a really lovely recipe if you want to give it a try: <a href="https://www.loveandlemons.com/kale-pesto" target="_blank">https://www.loveandlemons.com/kale-pesto</a>/  I use cashew seeds instead of pepitas because we always have them on hand. Favorite was: "Love of the past" for OLDFLAME. Cheers, all!

10 recommendations2 replies
Caroline KearneyBrooklyn, NYApr 30, 2025, 10:30 PMneutral49%

@HeathieJ - I used to go to a great diner in lower Manhattan with colleagues for lunch. Oddly, my colleague from a working class Jewish background made fun of me, from a lace curtain Irish background, for ordering corned beef hash. She seemed to think it was declassee.

3 recommendations
TeresaBerlinApr 30, 2025, 8:29 AMpositive96%

I loved it for the grown-up cluing, interesting words, lack of made-up random phrases and only a little entertainment trivia, which was actually interesting.

9 recommendations
Andy GSt. PeteApr 30, 2025, 12:15 PMpositive98%

Fun little way to start my Wednesday. My dog is thankful this was a fast solve, he gets to go out now.

9 recommendations1 replies
KatieMinnesotaApr 30, 2025, 1:29 PMpositive83%

@Andy G My cat is happier when the solve is longer. She gets to stay curled up on my shins while I'm puzzling things out.

7 recommendations
KenMadison WIApr 30, 2025, 12:47 PMpositive97%

Man, I wish I could make puzzles this good. 👍👍👍 Adam!

9 recommendations
CyndieEl Dorado HillsApr 30, 2025, 4:36 PMnegative70%

DACA, ACA. I miss that guy. TIL it’s not THETIMEISRIghT. No KALE SALAD for me, thanks. I’ll take the HASH or maybe the STEW. Nice one, Adam!

9 recommendations1 replies
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 30, 2025, 5:04 PMneutral55%

@Cyndie “The time is right” is also a common phrase. Just not the right one here.

5 recommendations
RhonnieFremont, CAApr 30, 2025, 2:13 AMpositive74%

Flew through that one. Very clean and straightforward

8 recommendations
Jamie BOregonApr 30, 2025, 5:27 AMneutral50%

It was fine. The two clues that went along with the main theme were clunky and didn't really make any sense as to why one was what it was and the other was what it was... Oh well, on to tomorrow.

8 recommendations
Jane WheelaghanLondonApr 30, 2025, 7:39 AMpositive94%

Nice one. OLD FLAME was good fun, and PEGLEGS and ROADS. I have heard of CLEAN ONES CLOCK, but not KATANA, or LOLLYGAG. This went by smoothly and pleasantly. I do wonder though, does a crossword exist which does not have a film reference? Asking for a friend.

8 recommendations8 replies
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 30, 2025, 7:49 AMpositive92%

@Jane Wheelaghan That's so interesting you have not heard of KATANA! It never ceases to amaze me how different the life experiences of people can be - for some reason, KATANA has been popping up throughout my very Polish and un-Japanese life. I suppose gaming is the reason? Interesting 🙂

9 recommendations
Helen WrightNow In Somerset UKApr 30, 2025, 12:51 PMpositive51%

@Jane Wheelaghan The first one is a new one on me too. I do know KATANA from my Japanese speaking elder son, but LOLLYGAG only through the spelling Bee!

4 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiApr 30, 2025, 1:09 PMnegative67%

Welp...the SE took me longer than the entire remainder of the puzzle.... I can't explainit except that "Silly ones" (Comics? Fools? Simons? No, that's SIMPLE ) had me stumped....and then "Inbox" made me think of the desk tier with TBD (?ToBeDone? ) and then "Spat" was either the over-shoe fancy-dress thingie or past tense of SPIT (PTUI? SKEWER? IMPALE?) so I just got farther out on that limb, and finally ADA!!! (Just one too many battles with the school system over the Americans with Disabilities Act regulations about "reasonable accommodations") and finally the (too late to help us) ACA dawned on me, as I lay exhausted in the ROAD.... After the nickel dropped, zip zip, and I even enjoyed seeing the CLOCK FACE and HANDS.... so cute. New to me: CENSOR BAR (Stupid thing supposedly disguising people in photos, etc.)...I didn't know it had a name.... Frances Perkins: a genius and a humanitarian... Rather a contrast, eh?

8 recommendations4 replies
K BarrettCAApr 30, 2025, 2:59 PMneutral56%

@Mean Old Lady Frances Perkins should be on the 20 dollar bill.

6 recommendations
kilaueabartOakland CAApr 30, 2025, 4:43 PMnegative75%

@Mean Old Lady That was the corner I had to turn to the Column for. Besides the problems you mention, I couldn't imagine HASH in a diner. People would pay for hash? (Nor did I know it could be made from meat and potatoes. I only sort of remember it, by name, from my childhood, 70~85 years ago.)

4 recommendations
Red CarpetSt PaulApr 30, 2025, 2:29 AMpositive99%

Great wave length match for me. Really enjoyed having down clues for the theme. That was a good mix up.

7 recommendations
Zane LyonsTacoma, WAApr 30, 2025, 7:32 AMnegative75%

The puzzle was fine, but the theme was weak to a point that it was distracting.

7 recommendations
Lee KelloggSomerville, MAApr 30, 2025, 12:09 PMpositive98%

I really liked this theme. Thought it was pretty clever and satisfyingly simple. Maybe on the easy side for a Wednesday but I'm not one to complain about that. Thanks a lot!

7 recommendations1 replies
JoanArizonaApr 30, 2025, 2:08 PMpositive56%

@Lee Kellogg I'd say it was average for the new standard of 'there will be cheats' Wednesdays these days. I needed four cheats. I liked the theme, and agree it was clever.

3 recommendations
dkNow in MississippiApr 30, 2025, 1:00 PMneutral53%

What time is it? I have hands and a face but I am not a clock. Dad joke number 11,230. Nice one. We are often confused by the various money terms as we are bears of little brain. Thank you Adam

7 recommendations1 replies
PaulNYApr 30, 2025, 11:16 PMneutral81%

@dk IT’S HOWDY DOODY TIME! But usually it’s 10:10…just take a look at any watch ad.

0 recommendations
AlexChiclayo, PeruApr 30, 2025, 6:29 PMpositive64%

Never heard of the phrase "clean one's clock" either. Perhaps the basis of a theme should be something more robust, but to be honest I thought this was a fun and satisfying puzzle nevertheless - thanks Adam!

7 recommendations
MeganAurora, COApr 30, 2025, 2:44 AMpositive77%

Very fast solve today. Had peglega ( think my brain was thinking aa was fixed on alas instead of sigh, but figured it out in the end

6 recommendations2 replies
Elizabeth ConnorsChicagoApr 30, 2025, 3:37 AMneutral76%

@Megan I did the same.

5 recommendations
Jacqui JRedondo Beach, CAApr 30, 2025, 4:03 AMneutral51%

@Megan 🙋🏼‍♀️ same here

4 recommendations
MichaelMinneapolisApr 30, 2025, 5:34 AMpositive92%

ENCUR, ASHRAD and TRIAMS had me reevaluating my initial appraisal of how easy this Wednesday puzzle was. The right answers, (INCUR, ASHRAF and TRIADS) were fairly simple to figure out, which is nice. Cheers

6 recommendations
SanjanaBombayApr 30, 2025, 10:40 AMpositive92%

Straightforward enough puzzle, had some nice clueing ('SAFARI' and 'CENSORBAR' were fun). I've never heard the phrase used in the theme before - a sentiment reflected in many comments - but once I put it together with the crosses, I felt it all click.

6 recommendations
JulianAnn Arbor, MIApr 30, 2025, 1:43 PMpositive94%

OLD FLAME got me good. I had OLD FLING instead!

6 recommendations
Times RitaNVApr 30, 2025, 3:52 PMneutral55%

I've never heard of any expression that had anything to do with cleaning anyone's clock. Nevertheless, I managed to finish the puzzle without resorting to looking anything up. Again, another puzzle that didn't float my boat.

6 recommendations
The Poet McTeagleCaliforniaApr 30, 2025, 8:33 PMpositive82%

Fun one, thank you! No double platinum hip-hop albums or HBO series actors to search for. . For a minute there I hoped 52A would be PITTSBURGH, but not enough spaces.

6 recommendations1 replies
The Poet McTeagleCaliforniaMay 1, 2025, 1:09 AMneutral55%

@The Poet McTeagle And 55A was not ORBITS...one letter too long.

0 recommendations
TTJNew YorkApr 30, 2025, 11:55 PMpositive94%

I was so proud when I solved the left "bottleful" clue to be HENNESSY. I had the H and the first N. As someone who does not drink, go me for getting a drinking-related clue! I was certain Hennessy had something to do with beating opponents soundly. I eventually solved the puzzle without any lookups. And I never heard of "cleaning one's clock" before. Yay! I'm getting better! Celebrating with a drink.... Tea.

6 recommendations2 replies
TTJNew YorkMay 1, 2025, 12:18 AMnegative67%

@TTJ Meaning if I drank, I'd feel soundly beat. I just realized my comment could be read wrong!

2 recommendations
JoyaNew YorkMay 1, 2025, 12:52 AMpositive94%

@TTJ that would have been fun to see in the puzzle lol!

2 recommendations
AlexisPerth, AustraliaApr 30, 2025, 2:12 AMpositive70%

The themers on either side made me giggle

5 recommendations1 replies
AlexisPerth, AustraliaApr 30, 2025, 2:18 AMneutral77%

Fast for a Wed though

4 recommendations
Kris HBerkeleyApr 30, 2025, 10:26 AMpositive60%

Nice puzzle! I wonder if this is the first appearance of Ashraf? If you do more puzzles, could you work in more Afghanistan references? Maybe something on Nasir Khusrow (of Badakhshan)? NYT I think you missed an opportunity to have little clock faces appear at the solve.

5 recommendations
Charles Nelson ReillyNYCApr 30, 2025, 7:37 PMnegative68%

What does time being ripe have to do with cleaning one’s clock. Stick to one figure of speech please. This puzzle is far from IDEAL. Also, how come I just solved Sunday and it’s coming up as a blue solve instead of a yellow solve? I didn’t use any check or reveal function. Finally, I was looking at a print copy of NYT from last week and noticed a lot of other puzzles, like the Cryptic. Why can’t we get those in the Games app?

5 recommendations8 replies
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNApr 30, 2025, 7:42 PMneutral91%

@Charles Nelson Reilly From Sam in today's column: "For instance, at 15A, [A reason to act this very instant … or why you might 6-Down 32-Down?] solves to THE TIME IS RIPE, because “ripe” refers to odor that might merit a cleaning."

6 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYApr 30, 2025, 8:10 PMneutral73%

@Charles Nelson Reilly When you do a puzzle out of chronological order, you can’t get a gold star. The second Sunday puzzles used to be available online at nytimes.com, but the powers that be decided not to make them available. The site xwordinfo.com, however, does make the second Sunday puzzles available to solve online (non-mobile only). There is an annual fee for this (I believe $20), but you also gain access to all the wonderful data available. In addition, you can solve pre-Shortz crosswords, which you cannot access at the NYT site. While it’s unfortunate that this is behind a pay wall, at least the NYT is not getting an additional money grab for the service, as xwordinfo is an independent site.

5 recommendations
JMNYCApr 30, 2025, 2:29 AMneutral62%

I’ve never come across a clock that had an odor, or at least I’ve never sniffed to check, but I’m sure someone out there has a good story to that effect.

4 recommendations6 replies
fionatimesMojaveApr 30, 2025, 4:07 AMpositive83%

@JM Agreed. The time is ripe just means it is a great time to do something. Ripe doesn't necessarily have anything to do with odor.

7 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandApr 30, 2025, 4:20 AMnegative83%

@JM In the 1990s, when Poland was recovering from the shock of the fall of the old regime and the many years of crisis that caused it, and democracy and market economy did not yet bring about increased prosperity, Polish train stations and trains became one of the most horrible places on earth - dirty, smelly, dilapidated and dangerous. 30 years later I can still remember the stench. And, actually, when I think of any train station paraphernalia, like those huge clocks, that unspeakable smell - of urine, iron, dust, sweat, motor oil, rotting trash, mould - accompanies the mental images. There is a famous 1989 song from the band Kult (which means Cult, and they are a cult band, funnily enough) with the line: Czy byłeś kiedyś w Kutnie na dworcu w nocy Jest tak brudno i brzydko Że pękają oczy oczy oczy Polska Mieszkam w Polsce Were you ever in Kutno [a town and train hub], at the train station, at night? It's so dirty and ugly your eyes will burst. Poland, I live in Poland I recommend Googling "Mieszkam w Polsce" by Kult and translating the lyrics via DeepL (which works much better than Google Translate) - they paint a very vivid, accurate, bleak image of this sorry country at the end of "communism." I'm so glad things have changed since then, dang 🤣

34 recommendations
Nora(American in) FranceApr 30, 2025, 8:01 AMpositive82%

@JM OK here's one. I was on my bike, scouting yard sales one fine Saturday. I found some treasures that day! A pair of wooden shoes, a stove-top popcorn popper, and an old handmade quilt. I loaded these into my bike basket and headed for home. The bike was a little top heavy and tippy, but everything was secure. I took a shortcut down a dirt road and spied a big sale at an old farmhouse. What luck! I looked through plows and jars and old oak dressers, when I saw it, a mantle-top pendulum clock. What a beauty! Great condition, how could I pass it up? After paying a pittance for the clock, I loaded it on my bike. I nestled it in the blanket and secured the whole thing with bungee cords. Success! Off I rode, giddy from my bargain hunting prowess. As I biked down the drive, a chicken darted into my path. I braked, I swerved, and I toppled over, right into the manure pile. The chicken was safe, but I was a mess. The clock fell off the top and landed face first. I picked up my bike, reloaded my basket, and gingerly rescued my new clock from its odiferous environs. The glass was shattered, and the front of the clock was caked with manure. Pee-yoo! "Well, I can get a new glass for this, and there's no other damage. It's nothing a little HAND SOAP and FACE WASH won't fix right up. I'm heading home now, because as my mother always said, when THE TIME IS RIPE, it's time to CLEAN ONE'S CLOCK!"

15 recommendations
BNYApr 30, 2025, 3:16 AMneutral51%

Really too easy I think. That seems to be a recurring, er, theme this week. This puzzle's actual theme was fine, a little subtle, and better than the "fill" that surrounds it. (This seems to be the opposite of someone else's opinion a few posts below me.) I wonder if it would have been a better puzzle if the constructor hadn't split up the phrase after all. It's Wednesday and I had to check a couple of times to make sure because it was going so fast... Ah well. ____________________ Jesse Goldberg 8/28/2024 for Puzzle of the Decade (emu filler)

4 recommendations
ByronTorontoApr 30, 2025, 8:24 AMpositive98%

What a fun and challenging Wednesday! Well done!

4 recommendations