An embankment in a large Oregon city is a Eugene levee. (These puns make a state-ment.)
@Mike So taxing. Can't believe you dredged that up.
@Mike Only if it’s holding back Schitt’s Creek!
A perfect Tuesday puzzle. Very clear theme but not one that's overdone, with clues at the Tuesday level. Great job, Peter Gorman!
This is a beautiful grid build. The answer set is remarkably smooth, considering the seven OREGONs plus a ten-letter revealer, which greatly constrict the answer possibilities. Adding to the constriction is that the OREGONs are all in a specific order. That is, starting with one of the O’s, you can spell OREGON without having to skip a square. Thus, you can have ORE NOG as in the lower middle of the grid, but you can’t have, say, REO GON because in going from OREG to ON, you’d have to make a jump. If the circles had been allowed to simply be anagrams of OREGON in any order, the grid would have been easier to fill. And, somehow, on top of all this, Peter was able to splash beauty into the grid, with OPHELIA, AGOG, DIABLO, PRIM, AEGIS, and IRONY. Plus, for me, a pair of bonuses. There was a TIL that “chortle” is a combo of “chuckle” and “snort”. Hah! Plus, there was the lovely PuzzPair© of GOGO and RUSHMORE. A nod of respect for your skill, Peter, not to mention gratitude for the fun solve and extras. Bravo!
I'm from Oregon! 🙂 (Just needed to say that!)
Final change was from TAS to RAS fixing a rather amusing mount TUSHMORE Maybe if they insist on adding a fifth it can be their … Nice puzzle. I’d like to see Bend but it’ll have to wait until 2029.
@Ιασων You made me imagine what Mt Tushmore would look like 🤣 2029, eh? My wife and I were planning a trip to NYC for the spring of 2025 but we called it off in November 2024. We're waiting for 2029, too. Bend and its area are well worth visiting.
@Ιασων 😂😂😂 If I thought that would happen, I could die a happy man. And I hope you can make it in 2029. And that we can make it until then. I've never really understood how Roosevelt (Theodore) fits with the others. Not that I don't like him, but compared to Washington and Lincoln... I used to think a lot more of Jefferson before I read the Meacham biography.
@Ιασων a la South Park?
I'm one of the first for a change. I don't know what to say, until everyone else has said it. I thought it was really easy, easier than Mondays. I think that's something we have to say every Tuesday. I also chuckled when I got the theme. I'm glad the inert gases got a call out. They are often considered lazy and arrogant, because they don't want to have anything to do with the other elements, for the most part. Personally, I like the noble gases. Helium can make you sound like a chipmunk, and xenon can make you sound like Barry White. And I've been a fan of Roger Ebert from his sneak preview days on public TV. That's all. I have to go breath some helium now.
@Francis We're on the same page today. So that's something. Which is nice. And go easy on the He; it's in permanently short supply.
@Francis "I'm glad the inert gases got a call out. They are often considered lazy and arrogant, because they don't want to have anything to do with the other elements, for the most part." I feel sorry for the column 18 gases: the way they are bullied by heartless chemists into forming compounds, even if they don't want to, purely to satisfy the chemists' egos. (I feel the same way about the trans-uranian elements; which means, I guess, those six atoms of Organesson got a double whammy.)
When I decided to move to Oregon twenty-five years ago, I kept being asked why I was moving to Oregon. "To get oregon-ized," I'd answer. (Unfortunately, I continue to be just good-enough organized.) At first, when I saw OREGON in the NW – and without examining the circles more closely – I thought we might be shooting for scattered states as if the grid were a U.S. map (Maine in the NE?) When the second OREGON revealed itself, I thereafter took advantage of the letters to help along the entries and for a little extra fun. And fun it was. Thank you, Mr. Gorman! (In honor of OPHELIA, here are The Lumineers: <a href="https://youtu.be/pTOC_q0NLTk?si=EK-66sTIK0Bz-rOM" target="_blank">https://youtu.be/pTOC_q0NLTk?si=EK-66sTIK0Bz-rOM</a>)
@sotto voce Nice. My first thought was Ophelia’s verse in Dylan’s Desolation Row: “ Ophelia, she's 'neath the window for her I feel so afraid On her twenty-second birthday she already is an old maid To her, death is quite romantic she wears an iron vest Her profession's her religion, her sin is her lifelessness And though her eyes are fixed upon Noah's great rainbow She spends her time peeking into Desolation Row.” <a href="https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2zbys3" target="_blank">https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2zbys3</a>
@sotto voce One more. Natalie Merchant singing (with lyrics). <a href="https://tinyurl.com/55jwpj23" target="_blank">https://tinyurl.com/55jwpj23</a>
@sotto voce I simply cannot dance, never could. As a consequence, I think, this guy's motion is utterly mesmerizing for me.
My wife and I visited Bend, Oregon in 2013, and we liked both the city and it's surroundings. The theme was quite fun, bending Oregon 🤪. It's good I knew AEGIS, because I had no idea what CYS might be (by now I had looked it up. To Polish eyes CY is such a strange looking name 😮. Since CY COLEMAN was apparently associated with musical theater [shudder] I've never heard of him). For a moment I doubted myself, and changed AEGIS to AEGId (egida is the Polish spelling of the word, so I thought, what the hell, maybe that's an acceptable variant in English, too), since CYd seemed to make more sense than CYS. However, when I got the "So close" popup, I changed that letter back to an S and got my gold star. (Nits: To be fair, the *Italian* grilled sandwich is a PANINo, and the American ENTREES for main courses, albeit a gimme, will always continue to surprise me) I'm going for a short trip with my father so I might not post for a day or two.
@Andrzej Honestly "Cy" looks like a pretty weird name to me too. I suppose it's short for Cyrus. "Syd" is a similar strange abbreviation....
@Andrzej I assume that, at least in most cases, Cy is the short for Cyrus. I don't know if anyone called Cyrus Vance "Cy," though. Seems doubtful.
@Andrzej Have a great time Andrzej. We'll be here when you get back.
Very clever theme and expertly executed. Let’s hear it for the Beaver State!
You’re on! That is, the people from yesterday who wanted I’M ON instead of I’M IN. You just had to wait a day.
This was such a clever theme! I too had NOBLEGAS instead of INERTGAS. I also had IKE instead of DDE. Got there in the end without going around the BEND.
@Lisa Marshall Just so you don't make the IKE mistake ever again... JFK was a signal that initials were needed. IKE has never been clued to another president's initials, although he has been clued to his own initials several times (mostly pre-Shortz). (The latter is valid because it's an equivalency.) But DDE has been clued to JFK (predecessor), HST (successor), RMN (running mate/boss), other abbreviations like POTUS, WWII, etc., and "inits." or "monogram". Hope this helps!
A grilled Italian sandwich is a panino. Multiple grilled Italian sandwiches are panini.
@Kim I found that error troubling as well.
@Kim Reposting myself from below: A PANINo is an Italian sandwich, a PANINI is an Italian-style sandwich everywhere outside Italy. Of course today's clue is acceptable in crosswordese shorthand, but it begs for nits to be picked.
@Andrzej My husband lived in Italy for 6 years. His dad was in the army, stationed in Vicenza. He often talked about how he and his friends would stop for a 'panini' during their days spent riding their motorcycles. I don't ever remember him calling it a panino, but of course, he wasn't Italian, and didn't speak the language except for a few phrases. In any case, he said they were delicious, and missed the food there once they came back to the states.
@Kim - At my last birthday party they threw only one confetto. Sad.
@Kim Just here to represent for the tamales.🫔 Octopi love themselves a couple warm tamales.
@Kim yeah, but we're not conversing in Italian, we're in English. The singular grilled sandwich is a panini, multiple would be paninis.
Entrees always throws me. An Entree in Oz is a starter dish, not a main course Also what am I missing with Uncle? I got it from the crosses Once I got the theme it was a fun little fill
@Throckmorton To ”cry uncle” is to give up, admit defeat.
@Throckmorton The clue (5D) for ENTREES was [Main courses]. What does that have to do with Oz?
@Cherry Oz is Australia. In Oz and many other places, an ENTREE is a starter not the main course.
@Throckmorton Maybe I'm the only one here who grew up in Brooklyn and had a U.S. born mother, daughter of Eastern European immigrants, who also called a starter dish an entree. So not just in OZ or the U.K. But that's what it should be, since its root means "enter," or "begin."
@Cherry Throckmorton is in Australia. "Oz" is a slang word for Australia.
@Throckmorton Whenever I run across your handle I smile as I am reminded of the eponymous “sign” we learned in medical school when reading radiographs of the pelvis. Cheers!
@Throckmorton Yeah the entree = main dish is pretty much US only. Who knows how that happened? It comes directly from French, where entrée is the starter, because the word means entrance. Makes sense, eh? Merriam Webster has an explanation, but IMO it doesn't hold water too well. <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/entree" target="_blank">https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/entree</a>
Clever theme resulting with a fun solve, and yes, Peter I did enjoy the solve.
Wow, a lot of people are upset about PANINI. I have literally always seen PANINI used to mean a single sandwich. I don't even know what the singular form would be--panin? Wikipedia tells me it's panino, a word I have never seen in my life, and I have eaten a lot of sandwiches. It also says panino is not a common word. Guys, it's a PANINI.
@Katie As the Pink Panther once said, "Pedant, pedant, pedant, pedant, pedant..."
@Katie Why don't you expand your horizons and take Italian 101? Guys - it's panino for one of them, and panini for two of them. Knowledge is power.
@SteveL I feel so sad that you haven't responded to D Johnson, who is very obviously new in these here parts, to correct him on his obviously very incorrect assumptions about you. But I know you have a lot going on these days, so I'll hold off on popping the popcorn and enjoying the show. 🧡 ☺️
I originally thought the theme would be the OREGON trail, that is until I saw the final theme clue. Very clever and perfectly Tuesday. Seeing AARON BURR makes me think of the Got Milk? commercial from a while back 🤣 <a href="https://youtu.be/0Gkqzxss8Ss?si=uK0FiRXYA-C9mbfC" target="_blank">https://youtu.be/0Gkqzxss8Ss?si=uK0FiRXYA-C9mbfC</a>
@Jacqui J Love the “Got Milk?” Commercial! They had a brilliant marketing team! This is my all-time favorite commercial, which is also theirs: <a href="https://youtu.be/eph6_fz49rc?si=_q5tl9_2SWDoqi4B" target="_blank">https://youtu.be/eph6_fz49rc?si=_q5tl9_2SWDoqi4B</a>
PANINI definition: <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/panini" target="_blank">https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/panini</a> <a href="https://www.collinsdictionary.com/us/dictionary/english/panini" target="_blank">https://www.collinsdictionary.com/us/dictionary/english/panini</a> <a href="https://www.dictionary.com/browse/panini" target="_blank">https://www.dictionary.com/browse/panini</a> <a href="https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/panini" target="_blank">https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/panini</a> <a href="https://www.thefreedictionary.com/Panini" target="_blank">https://www.thefreedictionary.com/Panini</a> <a href="https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/panini" target="_blank">https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/panini</a> <a href="https://www.yourdictionary.com/panini" target="_blank">https://www.yourdictionary.com/panini</a> Now will all the pseudopedants please stifle yourselves and go have a nice panini. Or a tamale. Or some octopi. Unless, of course, "the dictionary is wrong." Language. Evolves. Sic transit gloria panini.
@Steve LNever shall I let a dictionary determine my opionions about language. Why bow to authority when you can be a free thinker. Language has been around for 200 millenia or so; dictionaries for a mere fraction of that. Let all human beings retain sovereignty over their own usage. After all, this is how change comes about although many may not like it, and I usually don't. Also, deferring to the dictionary nips many an interesting conversation in the bud.
@Steve L Not that I don't appreciate your comment. I may need to borrow "Sic transit gloria panini" from you. May it find its way into a dictionary somewhere.
@Steve L Pseudopedant??!! I resemble that comment.
i am EXTREMELY relieved that 7D has nothing to do with that pseudo US government department with the same letters that is destroying our country. 337 people out of about 1500 in just one division of HHS retired or were fired last week.
@RozzieGrandma Unfortunately they are both Elon-Musk related. He was a big fan of the coin, and that led to his "jokey" development of the name for the cruel US department.
BTW, the title of the puzzle, Think Out Loud is a nod to Dave Miller's noon M-F talk show on Oregon Public Broadcasting. Miller is an Oregon treasure. His show involves all things Oregon, from all parts of Oregon. It is the kind of show that includes everybody. And discusses everything. He is respected by everyone. A generalist, his interview style is friendly, probing, and inciteful. Everyone should hope to have someone like Miller in their state doing a radio show like his.
@pat in oregon Just so you know, that's the headline for the Wordplay column. Only Sunday puzzles have titles. The show does sound interesting though.
@pat in oregon Do you know if any of his shows are on-line and accessible for non-Oregonians? BTW, Oregon is one of the half dozen states I've never been to, and it's also somewhat mysterious to me. I have a sense of what most states are like: Arkansas, Alaska, Vermont...but Oregon doesn't seem to fit into any particular pattern. The east is prairie (or desert?), while the west is lush. A very diverse state.
Touch and go for TAG and Permanent location for SALON were brilliant and made me laugh out loud. A very cute and Tuesday appropriate puzzle.
Regarding a number of comments today: tomato / tomahto potato / potahto Let's call the whole thing off. ...
I got the theme RIGHT AWAY! (Note my hometown 😁)
An elegantly smooth puzzle, with some of my favorites included: the trustworthy critic; the poignant Shakespearean, almost heroine; and the clever way the whole name of one of my favorite actors was included, like icing on a top of a cake. There were other delicious tidbits as well, which made it all a pleasure to solve. Thank you, Peter Gorman, for a construction that was tricky and fun.
@dutchiris 3:45 a.m. thought: "Adrien" My apologies, Mr. Brody, and personal advice from the elderly: Never write comments in the thick of a terrible day.
I actually found this a little more difficult than the average Tuesday. Definitely doable, no lookups required, but it had enough chew to be engaging. I’ve never been to Bend, Oregon, but it appears to be full of twists and turns. Maybe someday I’ll have the flexibility to visit.
Whatever happened to “I done did this puzz” guy? I think about him sometimes.
@Lauren Ford FWIW, I think you are referring to Eddie from Kentucky. I suspect he’ll show up before long, given his huge following.
@Lauren Ford maybe he hasn’t been done doing the puzz :/
@Jeb Jones He lives in Eriepa.
@Jeb Jones He was born Benito d'Oregano. Got changed at Ellis Island.
@Jeb Jones He's Ben Dover's cousin.
Ahh, the perennial panini/panino thing. Never gets old...
Funny and unexpected reveler. Nice puzzle, Peter! I love seeing the chain yanking PANINI, and all of the outrage it generates. Maybe the NYT is trying to drive up traffic.
@Nancy J. I guess the unexpected reveler was DDE, but I meant the revealer, BEND OREGON.
@Nancy J. It's not outrage, so much as annoyance from the lack of rigor from the constructor and the editor, who should know and love the use of language. I remember when Alex Trebek would get agiated from "Brussheta" pronounciation. Using "panino" would have been so elegant and satisfying, as well as being correct.
@Maire Merriam Webster has panini as the usual singular form, and says panino is uncommon. So how do you figure it for lack of rigor?
Now this is a brilliant puzzle. Inspired, outside-the-box theme idea executed cleverly with some sparkling fill and an a-ha revealer. Spectacular Tuesday. 3:28.
Got the theme really fast - in my first pass with acrosses. Saw it in the NE corner, and was able to get the other circle areas filled in quickly. But.... I reached the revealer and Oregon Trail didn't fit! I was so sure that was what it was going to be!
Like others here, I expected an Oregon Trail revealer, but i was so pleasantly surprised to see BEND. It’s such a beautiful town in a gorgeous region—I haven’t been there in years, but every time I get a Deschutes’ beers (which is every time I see one on offer), I’m flooded with pleasant memories. Also, I really enjoyed this puzzle! The bright fill and bent OREGONs made for a quick, fun solve. Thanks, Peter Gorman & ed’s.
@Josh I was looking for Oregon Trail in a revealer as well. I never made it as far as Bend, but I did drive through Grant's Pass on the way to Mount Bachelor. (I was staying with a GF in Eugene.) I'll keep an eye out for Deschute's.
@Josh In a post below, I mentioned drinking a lager from Costco: in the fine print on the can, I read that it was brewed by Deschutes', and distributed by Costco, labelled as Kirkland
If you cut a panino into two pieces, is it now a panini? If you do the cutting in a forest, with nobody around, was it really cut? (Sam)which came first? The panino or the panini? And why isn't it panina and panine? Patriarchy? Question, question, questioni. Humans have three questioni.
@Francis I wanted to give you a chef's kiss emoji but my emoji bank doesn't have one. Maybe I should try looking for an emojo instead.... Hmm. Anyhow, thought you'd like a zombie instead. 🧟♀️ 😉
This one was pretty smooth for me, with the exception of the CYS/AEGIS crossing. A couple of years AGO, my imagination might’ve taken me anywhere on that one. But with some hard-earned crossword LOGIC telling me that “and others” usually means the answer ends in S. And with our resident UNCLE @SteveL echoing “Use the cross, Luke” in my mind, I breezed through it without much issue.
@Striker Funny you should call me UNCLE. In our family, our two adult children and our adult niece and nephew, and all of their spouses (and our grandniece) often get together for visits. In referring to me in group texts and large-group conversations as "Uncle Daddy". (I call her "Aunt Mommy," too.)
I’ve somehow gone my whole life without seeing “ECONO” used as shorthand. My problem, not the constructor’s; this was a fun and relatively breezy solve.
@Stephen Usually as part of a longer name: Think EconoLodge or Ford Econoline.
44A I’m nitpicking here, but one “grilled Italian sandwich” is a PANINO. Multiple sandwiches are PANINI.
@Michele Probably figuring common usage in the US is to use PANINI to mean one sandwich, even though it's not correct.
@Michele yes I came to pick that exact nit myself. Mostly I’m ticked that I didn’t pencil it in to remind myself to check against the cross since I knew there was a good chance it would be the wrong, American usage.
@Michele Once a word is adopted into English from another language, spelling and usage may change. You all know that the word in question is no longer Italian, it’s adopted from Italian. The dictionary can usually answer questions about words.
@Michele, I was also momentarily cursed by having a working knowledge of Italian. Thanks for pointing this out. It’s the only nit I have to pick in an otherwise cleverly-themed puzzle.
@Michele Merriam Webster notes panini as the usual singular form with panino as relatively uncommon.
@Michele Merriam Webster not only lists "panini" as a valid English singular, but lists "paninis" as the plural.
Man, wait until all these pedants find out my singular (in every way) dog is named Cannoli.
@Diana I think I’ll have a zucchino for dinner. Or a raviolo, maybe more than one.
When I first started to figure out the theme of the puzzle, I worried I was going to die of dysentery. I was really relieved that it only led me to BENDOREGON. Phew!
@HeathieJ 😜😆🙃 <a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/how-you-wound-playing-em-oregon-trailem-computer-class-180959851" target="_blank">https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/how-you-wound-playing-em-oregon-trailem-computer-class-180959851</a>/
@HeathieJ, Whew! That was a close one! I’m friends with a man who was one of two or three young programmers who wrote Oregon Trail for an educational organization years ago. Another mutual friend “blamed” him for making his daughter cry every time she played that game, because there was always someone who didn’t make it. 😀
The only city I could think of was Portland, but it would only fit as PORTLANDOR or maybe PORTLANDIA. It wasn't until I did a buch of the crosses that I realized it was Bend and had a good CHORTLE.
Fun, cute, really easy, and with a good theme I didn't fully get until the revealer. Just about perfect for a Tuesday. (And much easier than yesterday's weirdness.) Maybe one of them thar platonic ideals of a Tuesday puzzle, as the cool kids are wont to say...
@B So you *were* serious yesterday 😮 I was sure that was sarcasm!
That was pretty clever and a fun solve.
A fun puzzle to be solving from my hometown of Bend, a treasure of the west. Bendite puzzlers, sound off!
@alpal Solved this in the back room of Bevel Brewing, one of the few breweries still frequented by locals. 🍻
@alpal Yep, nice puzzle. Roundabout? Signal out!
When I saw PANINI in the puzzle, I knew today would not be a good day do a shot each time the same puzzle nit came up... With my inclusion of it here, I'd be 64 shots in!! (And another 28 if I include PANINo. Yikes!! But you know, there are so few things in life we can really count on. It's sort of reassuring that perennial prodigious panini pandemonium will always be a surety in this comment section.
@HeathieJ When I saw PANINI, the first thing I wondered is how many complaints would pepper the comments?
Had noble instead of inert gases at first. But the crosses didn’t fit. Didn’t we see Eros clued the same way yesterday? I can never remember how to spell blige but fixed it with crosses. 3:45 bettter than my average. Actually watched a live demonstration of Plein-air painting once. Was pretty cool. Enjoyed the Theme
@Megan Not sure about zeros, but there have been a lot of repeat answers the last few days. I recall seeing: ASAMI RIGID IMON Multiple times recently.
@Megan Never confuse Blige with bilge! Ask me how I know! Arrgh!
A main course is not by definition an Entree.
@Spmm. Unless you happen to live in America. I know that I have the same reaction every time.
@Spmm And a “panini” is not a grilled Italian sandwich. A panino is a sandwich, grilled or not. Panini is the plural form of panino.
@Spmm seemingly everywhere, except the US. 🤷🏻♂️ <a href="https://www.casaschools.com/blog/why-americans-say-entree-for-main-course" target="_blank">https://www.casaschools.com/blog/why-americans-say-entree-for-main-course</a>/
@Spmm G'day, mate. Or, should I say, g'night, since it's morning in America, so it must be nighttime in Oz. In the US, a "mate," BTW, is a husband or wife, or at least a longtime significant other. It's not a pal or a buddy. As the article Paul linked indicates, the original ENTREE was neither a starter/appetizer (as they say by you) nor a main dish (as they say here), but rather a course that was served between the two, which no longer exists in most places. Rather than ditching the word in both places, Anglophones decided to reassign the French word to another course, because, well, it's French. Unfortunately, they assigned it to different courses. I suggest that at this point, we table the discussion for later, and everyone who is complaining have a tamale.
"Panini" is plural. A single sandwich is a "panino".
Fun! I saw the pattern in the circles and got all of them before figuring out the hint clue, at which point I mentally slapped my forehead because I’ve been to Bend.
Oh, and another late puzzle find. A Sunday from August 11, 2013 by Dan Schoenholz with the title "Added Satisfaction." A couple of clue answer examples: Where most things rank in importance to a Muslim? : AFTERALLAH Webster's directive to the overly formal? : JUSTSAYNOAH Equipment list for a hashish-smoking fisherman? : HOOKAHLINEANDSINKER And a couple of other theme answers: AUNTIEAHEM HEADTOTAHOE Here's the Xword Info link: <a href="https://www.xwordinfo.com/Crossword?date=8/11/2013&g=102&d=A" target="_blank">https://www.xwordinfo.com/Crossword?date=8/11/2013&g=102&d=A</a> ...
14A. The clue [Permanent location?] refers not to a building or other structure At first I thought it would be GRAVE. :(