fun but almost impossible to see which clue is highlighted and active through all the colors.
@cfmoore You took the words right out of my mouth. Clever puzzle.
Why must people be so negative whenever we're given such a unique (and wonderful) theme? Was it a bit challenging to see? Slightly. Was it worth it? Absolutely.
And the gold medal goes to… Paolo! How often does one gasp “oh wow” when first opening the puzzle? The BLUEPRINT gave the blueprint for how this would work, so it wasn’t the hardest thing ever, but it was fun to zip around the rings filling them in. The hardest thing was navigating the colors to know which entry I was on. Got a little dizzy- just like I would if attempting any of the amazing physical feats the Olympians perform. Oh well we all have our talents. Today I won a gold medal in raspberry picking.
Unfortunately, I can’t read much of this puzzle. The colors make it difficult to see where the numbers are and where the answers go. Does anyone else have a similar problem? I’m wondering if it would be clearer in print.
@Alan There is a link to the pdf of the print version of the puzzle towards the end of Caitlin's column. One could also shut off Show Overlays in the Settings if in the Games app.
@Alan if you go to the settings icon (the gear looking thing) you can disable overlays and it goes to grey scale. Then turn it on when you need the help of the colors.
Trying this again. Emus. please stand back! Alan, It is clearer in print. Here is the link Vaer referenced: <a href="https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/01f9b4868e3a114a/caf26974-full.pdf" target="_blank">https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/01f9b4868e3a114a/caf26974-full.pdf</a> That's a NYT link, emus; it's OK. ###########
Well, I SAY! Now that was fun!! Really enjoyable!! Yea, it was harder to know where you were on the grid, so I had to rely more on actually looking at the box numbers but I think it was worth it! I figured out the trick at MAGIC because (as a huge Harry Potter fan), I was annoyed that the implication was that any MAGIC was malevolent... and then came the AHA! And then came the chuckle, and then came a flurry of filling in the colored squares. Most of those filled in easily once I got the trick but a couple had to wait for crosses. Today we got OLIVE and ONION! Hold the OLIVEs for me but I'm always glad for ONIONs! I didn't make good time... I was actually over average. I'd say it was a combo of struggling a bit to keep track of myself in the grid until I got used to it and there were some tricky spots for me, as usual. There were a small handful of answers I just didn't know, which sometimes crossed with others I didn't know. A couple times I thought I might have to do a lookup, but I kept at it and worked it all out without helps. Huzzah!! I was perplexed for a while, never having watched Dumb and Dumber but I loved SILENT B once I got it! Also loved EAR CANAL (Channel with only audio) and TAKE THE BAIT (Get hooked). But really, the whole thing was very fun! And though I was surprised to see G SPOT show up in a puzzle (I SAY!), I'll take it any day over the clue for FEMININE SIDE in the Saturday puzzle. 😃
@HeathieJ @HeathieJ This is the 15th time that GSPOT has been in the puzzle according to the "Clue and Answer Finder" over at xword.info This term appeared first on March 3, 1996 clued as: -10 Across 1982 best seller on sexuality, with "The" Public Service Announcement for Jim Horne and Jeff Chen who run that site: Consider becoming a paid member to support this valuable resource for the puzzling community. <a href="https://www.xwordinfo.com" target="_blank">https://www.xwordinfo.com</a>/ BTW, Jim Horne was the first author of this "Wordplay" column. Here is a link to his final column, published on Christmas Day 2010: <a href="https://archive.nytimes.com/wordplay.blogs.nytimes.com/author/jim-horne/?_r=0" target="_blank">https://archive.nytimes.com/wordplay.blogs.nytimes.com/author/jim-horne/?_r=0</a>
I loved this puzzle! Sure, solving on the phone required some patience and zooming in due to the colors interfering with the highlighting, but it was absolutely worth it. I meandered around the puzzle, as I usually do until I know what's going on, but (Blue) BAYOU gave me the big aha, and I was suddenly energized to fill in all the rings. Aside from the rings, all the fill packed a nice punch and came together beautifully. Thank you, Paolo, for a brilliant puzzle! And now, I'll be on my way to other things, because TIME AND TIDE wait for no one. But I leave you with Freddie Mercury: <a href="https://youtu.be/D0MH00SNlSU?feature=shared" target="_blank">https://youtu.be/D0MH00SNlSU?feature=shared</a>
@sotto voce Thanks for the great link!! Enjoyed listening to it as I perused the comments and such!! 😊
@sotto voce Wait, what, “zooming”? I don’t know if I never tried before or if it’s only recently been possible, but thanks to your comment, I will never need to squint again to see those oh-so-tiny Sunday numbers. Just pinch-zoom (or unpinch-zoom?) works, at least on the iOS app. 👏
Cute theme, really hard to read in the app. I often couldn’t tell which clue I was on. I toggle between the across and down clues continuously because I’m one of those “cross solve only” folks (is there a term for us solvers who can only attempt a clue if it intersects a previously solved clue?). So not being able to see which clue I was on was an annoyance in an otherwise fun puzzle. Also ran this one by my red-green colorblind son and he couldn’t distinguish the colors. Not a biggie; he’s used to struggling occasionally in a color-based world. But I’ll always throw some awareness whenever color is fundamental to a game that color-based play doesn’t work for a significant portion of the population. Hats off to all of the other people with cone differences who had an extra challenge today!
@Jody cross-solvers works. :) Lately I’ve been doing all the across clues then cross-solve from there.
Pablo Pasco wins gold medal in Sunday Crossword competition. Bravo!
This puzzle rings true. (It'll test your medal!)
@Mike Now you've shown your true colors. /Emus in the shade, not ex-tint
@Mike I thought this puzzle was a piece of cake but it turned out to be a fool’s tart
Mike, I salute your unflagging dedication to the sport of punning. :) Only once have I noticed a bit of a lame one from you (to which I am sure others, being surprised to hear you would ever not perform well, might say: “Oh - limp he had?”)
I can't believe how much work must have gone into this puzzle. The four words in each of the five circles that made sense with the circle colors was genius. Hats off to Paolo Pasco – excellent job!
When I saw Paolo’s name atop the grid (I love his clever puzzles), and saw the grid itself – rectangular, colorful, and with what looked like a this-will-be-fun-to-crack complicated-looking network spanning the middle, I smiled with anticipation. Not just inwardly smiled, but the real deal. That network turned out to be not so complicated, but I was already charmed, and the good mood held throughout the fill-in. Paolo loves to wordplay in his clues. This is the man who once took an ordinary answer – HELMET – and made it extraordinary through his clue [Knight cap]. Today he did the same with RENT (clued “Number for a letter?”), GREENHOUSE (clued “What has a lot of room to grow?”), and NONS, (clued “Negative Nancy words?”). That last one is SO clever. Sure, punning on the French city Nancy has happened aplenty in crosswords. But here, Paolo beautifully misdirects, because a “Negative Nancy” is a thing, like a Debby Downer and Doubting Thomas. So, Paolo’s clue double hides the Nancy pun – brilliant! Fun to see ARCANA hiding in EAR CANAL, and lovely to see the gorgeous phrase TIME AND TIDE. Good vibes all around. Paolo, this had to be a tough tough build. Thank you for putting in the effort, because it sure paid off for me!
@Lewis Thanks for pointing out the Nancy pun. I thought the answer I typed was NOS, so I missed the pun.
@Lewis I agree. I loved the Nancy clue. 🇫🇷
A clever idea that I’m sure was difficult to construct: For each of the five colors, you need four five-letter words that are are part of common things like (BLACK) MAGIC or (RED) SCARE). Then, you need to put each one in the right part of the grid in such a way that you can fill the rest of the grid. This puzzle essentially has 23 theme answers, counting the revealer and the hints at 17A and 20A. All those fixed answers make it much more difficult to fill the grid well. So it’s too bad that the colors made it very difficult to solve in the app. I turned off overlays almost immediately, and that helped a lot. Still, I expect this would have worked much better in print. Great constructor note, though.
A puzzle that immediately draws a smile when you see the colors and the rings. Once you grasp the concept, it is perhaps too quickly solved for a Sunday. But, I'm feeling the Olympic spirit, so this was enjoyable. Plus vite, plus haut, plus fort – ensemble.
Puzzle was easy; theme was cute; data entry was absolutely miserable! As others have already said, the color handling made it nearly impossible to see what row or column was being highlighted in the web version of this puzzle. It was a real chore. Admittedly I was already pushing the limits by doing Sunday puzzles on a cell phone screen, but today's interface was punishing. Please don't do this again. The pain was not worth it for the modest gain of cluing simple answers like blue birds and yellow bellies. Puzzle overall was fine, although really too easy for a Sunday by my expectations....
@B Thanks for writing what I was thinking! I turned off the overlays almost immediately, and found the gray squares easier on my eyes. Unfortunately, I hadn’t yet grasped the significance of the colors. For all I knew, (GREEN) GIANT is now just GIANT, but then I buy the store-brand frozen spinach and broccoli. But as you said, the answers were simple enough to grasp the color component easily.
In case anyone is wondering, the normal Sunday grid is 21 x 21, and today's is 19 x 23, making today's puzzle four squares fewer than the usual Sunday. You're welcome. Et tu, emu.
@Lewis Ah, algebra! (n - 2)(n + 2) = n² - 4 (Let n = 21.) Do we need more emus working in STEM fields?
@Lewis We wuz robbed! I want a refund! !!! !!! !!! !!! Emus can multiply...that's why there are so many of them....
Great puzzle! Really rough for the colorblind, though. Really really.
I continue to be disturbed by the choices to include clues legitimizing the occupation of Palestine. It's not an "Israeli desert," it's the al-Naqab desert in Palestine.
E., Rather than commenting here on such a subject, I suggest you send a letter to the publisher of The Mannahatta Times. Salaam.
Echoing many others, the theme is fun, but it's absolutely impossible to see what clue I am on in the mobile version! Doesn't matter if I'm in dark or light mode or how bright/dim the screen is.
This was a fun Sunday with a well executed gimmick and great cluing. I have aging eyes too, so I solved it on my laptop with my reading glasses on. You smartphone users know the joke about the man who goes to the doctor? "Doc, it hurts when I do this!" he complains, and the doctor replies "Well, don't do that!"
Okay, clever. I may be yelling at the clouds, but I prefer a good old fashion black & white grid.
Well, how can you not love a puzzle whose 13th column begins with DENIAL RIVER? Et tu, emu.
I appreciate the creativity of the grid, but I had to quit after a few clues. MY EYES.
@Bruce, I told my husband that I thought I might have to break down and get readers. At 46 it was a brag of mine to not need them. This puzzle made me question that assertion. Happy to see it wasn’t just me.
@Bruce ditto. Beautiful puzzle. But impossible to figure out where I was going to type with all the subtle color differences. Not a glass issue in my humble opinion.
I was just going to do a little of the puzzle before starting dinner. But I was having so much fun, I couldn't stop. I was a wee bit dense about what was going on with the fill and the colors at first, but Linda Ronstadt and Blue BAYOU was my big AHA moment. I see OLIVE is back as a pizza topping, crossing the Green ring. My personal preference would have had it crossing the Black. :) Thanks Paolo.
@Vaer Olive is in the black ring. I didn't see this until the puzzle was solved, though.
Almost 9 min. slower than my Sunday avg. I couldn’t see what square my cursor was on, or whether I was solving across or down in the Games iPad app. Lots of stray letters for me. I eventually realized that I could turn off the overlay, but then I had to turn it back on to get [blue]print, [yellow]pages, etc.
The puzzle itself was fine. My main complaint is that because of the colors, I had a very hard time seeing where I was on the grid (or even if I was situated in the down or across direction). Thus, there was a lot of time wasted correcting mistakes. It was frustrating and visually disorienting. I wish that either lighter colors had been used or the rings could have appeared upon completion of the puzzle.
@Lawillibug I had the same problem, resulting in an experience that part of my brain really enjoyed, and another part found very frustrating! Maybe if they had outlined the colored sections instead of shading them in?
What a great puzzle. I stayed up late to finish because I was enjoying it so much. I enlarged the print/grid so I wouldn't go blind trying to read the letter boxes. Once enlarged, it was easy to read. The different colors were clear. Joe Flagliano must be a genius. I'm so impressed with this creative and very lovely work of art. A gold medal achievement. Thank you for a delightful evening puzzling. Blue Bayou ear worm going on. I love the way Helen Ronstadt sang that lovely song. She died too young. G'night from Texas.
Just to set the record straight... Linda Ronstadt is alive and well, although no longer performing.
@Bonnie Ann, Linda (not Helen) Ronstadt died? That must come as quite a shock to her … 😄
A reminder that the Negev desert is also called al-Naqab in Arabic, and the indigenous inhabitants were forcefully removed from their lands. To this day, the state of Israel does not recognize the remaining Bedouin inhabitants and has been relocating them into government towns. Disappointed the Times did not list both names for the desert in the clue. It matters, now more than ever.
@Sarah Should The NY Times list every USA city by its indigenous name? How about using Tawainese and Chinese names? How about Any other country that has a comp,ex history of inhabitants. Or is only Israel deserving to be singled out for such treatment? Once again Israel exceptionalism is incredible.
While clever, it was made EXTREMELY hard to solve online in the colored rings area, since it altered the highlighting color of the squares for the selected clue. It makes a pretty grid, and enables the color-oriented puns making up the rings, but adds unwanted minutes to the solve time. NOT A FAN
@BW agreed! I couldn’t even tell if I was in an Across or a Down!
We have a winner! I opened the app and just laughed at the setter’s Olympic-scale ambition — almost chutzpah!, and then I enjoyed working through the clever way that ambition was realized. I’m glad to say that unlike the real Olympics, the flag was not upside down — now that would have been real chutzpah! In case you missed it: <a href="https://time.com/7004336/paris-olympics-opening-ceremony-error-spotted-flag-upside-down" target="_blank">https://time.com/7004336/paris-olympics-opening-ceremony-error-spotted-flag-upside-down</a>/
Loved this puzzle! I did have some trouble navigating the middle (because of the colors and highlighting of the answer boxes) but it only slowed me a little. I enjoyed the Olympic theme (I had ring instead of flag for a bit at 114A) but didn't pick up on the added import of the colors right away. I entered MAGIC (38A) but was iffy about the negativity in the clue and entered ROBIN (40A) while thinking they must have dropped Red from the name. But then, at GIANT, I figured it out! I scurried around filling out all the clues in the rings. I struggled with only one: 43D [they fly over the rainbow]. I was thinking of the military air shows Blue Angels and couldn't get that out of my head until the crosses showed me the way! Thanks to Paolo for being so patient waiting for publication of this very well constructed puzzle and thanks to the Games team for the colors!
@SuzyQ Very similar experience! Got a happy glow just seeing the grid. Figured out the rings immediately, but didn't pick up on the added color meaning until STONE. Then got tripped up trying to make the middle ring gray. I know, I know, but I haven't been watching the Olympics this time and the rings had obviously paled a wee bit in memory. Only once did I have trouble seeing which square was being highlighted, but then reading the clue solved that. Wondered how it was for those on other platforms, though, so not surprised to see the comments.
There does not appear to be a place for Strands comments (I could be wrong) so I am going to say it here: Today's Strands was absolutely wonderful. It made me happy.
@Dee The “Bedtime Stories”? That wasn’t part of my childhood, so I was confused by the four-letter word in the upper left. But I get it now.
@Eric Hougland I enjoyed reliving GOODNIGHT MOON, a book we read dozens of times when my son was little.
Very nice puzzle but I found it visually challenging to see where I was on the grid solving it in the NYT games app.
I was fully expecting someone to post: "Who ever heard of an OTTOMAN SET???!!!" Then one of the Resident Correctors to post: "Well I googled it and here's a link bla bla bla. It's in the dictionary here bla bla bla. It's also in Wikipedia. Neener Neener." Dang. I leave disappointed.
Larry, You left too soon, but you might have been disappointed anyway. There *was* push-back about the OTTOMAN SET, but nobody pushed back on the push-back. See for yourself: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/40oia3?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share" target="_blank">https://www.nytimes.com/shared/comment/40oia3?rsrc=cshare&smid=url-share</a> Or ask an emu.
This puzzle became so tedious as my vision issues made it impossible to keep track of the cursor and highlighting across or down. Ohh, ahhh, rings, gee. Why couldn't they have filled in at the end of the puzzle like some of your other gimmicks do? And don't say print, the colors didn't print well and it looked like mud. Just. Do. The. Puzzle.
@TLC That occurred to me as well. But because each answer required the color, I think it would have been too hard for a Sunday if there were no indication until the end.
I'm not one who usually complains, but this puzzle was hard on the eyes and gave me a headache. I solved this problem by working on it in short stretches and taking breaks to focus my eyes on something else. It helped immensely and I ended up solving quicker than my average time. I loved the theme, and was giddy when I realized what was going on in the rings. By coincidence I was watching the opening ceremonies (on replay) while doing the puzzle. Thankfully the crossword didn't take nearly as long!
I’m so glad I have overlays off as the default in my app. In this case, not because it makes it easier to tell where you are in this puzzle, but because it adds another element to figure out in the puzzle (I also don’t look at the title until I finish). With overlays on, it is clear from the start that the Olympic logo is depicted, making the theme pretty obvious. With just grey (all the same shade) it is not clear at all what is going on or even that the shaded squares form five interlocking rings. I got RING BEARER pretty quickly, but FRODO BAGGINS was one letter too long for 114a 🤓. I soon figured out that colors had to be prepended to the shaded answers, and then soon after that realized it must be an Olympic theme. Though not knowing which five colors were used in the Olympic logo or the location of those colors added a little more guesswork. It was super-fun to figure those things out as I worked through the puzzle. I love a puzzle within a puzzle, and without ever seeing the colors (until I turned overlays on after completion) I got to enjoy that extra challenge. 😊 As a result, my experience solving this puzzle was a 10 out of 10. Even with the extra challenge though, it was a pretty easy Sunday. I finished in about 60% of my average time.
Color-blindness is the least recognized affliction in the US, even though there are more colorblind Americans (12 million!) than there are blind Americans. Color-based crossword puzzles are one of many instances in today's world with which the colorblind are forced to struggle. One would hope that, in these enlightened times, the needs of the colorblind would receive their proper due and appropriate adjustments would be made. This is not sour grapes on my part. I completed today's puzzle in under 28 minutes, which is pretty good considering the burden I bear. #AttentionMustBePlaid!
@Noah Vail What appropriate adjustments could be made? Just curious.
@Noah Vail Okay, I assume this is meant as satirical, but either way I find the comparison to blindness not at all amusing (though the hashtag is funny).
@Noah Vail et al (Noah, my dear maternal uncle was colorblind, and I did see that it affected him at times, but ne never really talked about it. Thanks for posting. ) Another perspective: Well, I print out my crossword puzzles, and MY puzzle was entirely in GRAY-SCALE (darker gray=black due to InkSaver; light gray=apparently some color or other, but in reality just GRAY......which was to be assumed and (apparently) presumed to be part of the answer. No crayons or markers were suggested or supplied to participants. No differentiation from one gray-faking-a -color to the next. There was a mosquito circling my head all the while, trying to help with the solve, but unable to make a contribution, she fell onto the paper print-out and cried herself to sleep. When I swatted her, the red SPLAT wasn't even in the right place. The whole scene was tragic.
Colored boxes made this really tough to navigate.
I wonder just how long it took to find a set of words that fit both the color and the crosses (and were straightforward to clue). A feat of Olympic proportions!
With respect to the distinguished constructor, Pan-Arabism and nationalism are usually contrasted, the former denoting a supposed sense of kinship transcending national identity, the latter an allegiance to the particular country of one's birth. Otherwise, typically excellent puzzle.
Also, if you haven't watched Severance starring Adam Scott... Do yourself a favor, the first season was excellent! The second season will be coming out soon! I cannot wait!!
@HeathieJ The last episode I was literally on the edge of my seat.
I loved this puzzle. Wonderfully clued and clever. I just wish the colors were more subdued…..it was sometimes hard to see.
Generally an enjoyable and clever puzzle. Finished roughly ten minutes under my Sunday average but since I solve on my tablet I also found this a bit frustrating, since I spent quite a bit of time trying to figure out where I was in the grid, because it was often unclear which squares were highlighted. Yes, I know the squares are numbered, but on my tablet the numbers are generally quite small, especially in the larger Sunday grid. Don’t get me wrong: I did enjoy it for the most part but maybe in the future the editors and coders (I assume there are coders) could take the issue of colored squares into account. I did, however, chuckle at 81 A [BLACK] OLIVE, because of the mild arguments about it as a pizza topping on Friday. On Friday, olives-on-pizza is a divisive issue; today it’s supreme. I guess it is a great, big, diverse world after all. (And I am in the “yes” camp for olives on pizza.)
@Joe Evidently, pineapple on pizza — a so-called Hawaiian pizza — is as controversial as black olives.
@Joe i think the reference is to a Supreme pizza, with all the toppings!
Good puzzle. Very tough to see/follow in the colored squares on the aop though.
In the digital version of today’s puzzle, I found it difficult to determine what cell I was in, where the current answer goes, which spaces were highlighted, etc. The colors did not work well at all.
Cool puzzle but my vision is perfectly fine and even I struggled with keeping track of where the active clue was in the app.
That is what I like to refer to as a “good, hard, steady slog” with lots of puzzlers that slowly reveal themselves with time, patience and the occasional break. A couple of stand outanswers that made laugh/smile: SILENTB EARCANAL Excellent puzzle imho.
Reading all the complaints I’m glad I decided to solve on a big iPad! Big beautiful puzzle with a clever theme. Yes it could be difficult to see the active square but I just paid attention to the highlighted clue. I think that’s a small price to pay for such a creative design. Ottoman sets is a bit of a stretch and I took the bait and put in RAMPS for CANTS at first. I’m aware of Cant, the verb and its gerund, Canting from high performance rigs and keels in sailing but didn’t know it was a noun too. How about that light show on the Eiffel Tower? Well done Paris!
@Roger Agreed on "ottoman sets." I'm an interior designer and I've never seen or heard anyone buying, selling or requesting an "ottoman set."