Thursday, August 7, 2025

500
Comments
0.054
Avg Sentiment
139
Positive
225
Neutral
136
Negative
Sort by:
SPCincinnatiAug 7, 2025, 2:52 AMnegative52%

Sigh looks like I need to repost this since the emus ate it the first time. Sorry if it posts twice. HecK I WIsh I had thought of this theme and that’s quite a compLIMEnt. It didn’t take ME LONg but I’d awarD A TEn to it. I hope it doesn’t elicit frustration nOR ANGEr in other commentators, nor inCUR RANTs. It made me delightfulLY CHEErful!

107 recommendations
MikeMunsterAug 7, 2025, 2:16 AMneutral54%

"You can't make this tropical fruit smoothie by yourself?" "It takes two to mango." (I go bananas for these puns.)

73 recommendations5 replies
JoshNew JerseyAug 7, 2025, 2:17 AMnegative71%

@Mike You're plum out of ideas

5 recommendations
Al in PittsburghCairo,NYAug 7, 2025, 4:30 AMnegative51%

@Mike I'll try to buy an acai mai tai. Sigh. Passion fruit didn't work. Goodnight, Mrs. Calabash, wherever you are. <a href="https://tinyurl.com/53dv6va6" target="_blank">https://tinyurl.com/53dv6va6</a>

13 recommendations
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:56 AMpositive76%

@Mike Me too!

4 recommendations
jmaeagle, wiAug 7, 2025, 1:43 PMneutral55%

@Mike In other words, you need a pear. I won't cherry-pick any other puns, and I'll leave the apple-ause to you.

10 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiAug 7, 2025, 2:27 PMnegative50%

@Mike Puns about fruits should only appear in season; please try to stay currant.

14 recommendations
Marshall WalthewArdmoreAug 7, 2025, 2:32 AMpositive96%

I was wandering around the puzzle FRUITLESSLY until I got the revealer. Then the clever themers became clear in a trice. I like it when the revealer unlocks a puzzle like that. Lots of good clues and very little filler. An all around winner. And for me a bonus — my law school alma mater (UPENN) showed up.

72 recommendations9 replies
D M MojoSan BernardinoAug 7, 2025, 2:39 AMneutral75%

@Marshall Walthew just wondering, does Philadelphia really make good cheesesteak sandwiches?

2 recommendations
DYTMinnesotaAug 7, 2025, 2:42 AMneutral83%

@Marshall Walthew Marshall=-- I would say exactly the same about my solving experience, except I would fill in the parenthetical with a different law school alma mater (30-across instead of 37-down), handily cross-referenced in the puzzle.

4 recommendations
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 3:06 AMnegative44%

Really a plum of a puzzle. And a perfect example of one that would have stopped me cold two years ago. Before I became aware of Anything-Can-Happen-Thursday, I would have quite with it about 25% filled, and no hope of figuring out anything else. As it was, I stumbled around badly until I finally got enough crosses for FRUITLESS_ _ . Even without the last two letters I now knew the trick, and instead of pounding my head against the wall with the clue, I looked for partly formed fruit names. Once found, then the clue was useful. A lot of fun, I thought. I wasn't especially speedy, and I thought once or twice that I was Going Down. In the end I didn't immediately get the happy music. I had mADD instead of SADD, in the extreme south west. But in the end, I had no raisin to grape.

64 recommendations
JimMarylandAug 7, 2025, 2:52 AMnegative50%

Yeah, thumbs down for PROBLEM ONE. Otherwise, a nice puzzle.

48 recommendations5 replies
Dave K.New York, NYAug 7, 2025, 3:16 AMnegative64%

@Jim Agreed, that isn't a thing. I've heard of "problem child", but never "problem one".

4 recommendations
Bill in YokohamaYokohamaAug 7, 2025, 3:45 AMneutral65%

@Jim Ditto SELF COMMAND over self control

21 recommendations
AlexisPerth, AustraliaAug 7, 2025, 6:45 AMnegative84%

@Jim I tried googling it and came up with nothing. Even google’s loathsome AI says “The phrase ‘problem one’ is too vague. To provide a helpful response more context is needed.”

5 recommendations
Margaret from BrooklynBrooklynAug 7, 2025, 5:19 PMnegative62%

@Jim It feels like PR-speak, along the lines of "Here at Acme, your safety is Job One." But my Google search only turned up one meme: "Problem one: you're completely bald." That doesn't seem like enough to conclude that it's in the language.

3 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandAug 7, 2025, 4:35 AMpositive66%

🐶🐯🦙 The cute puppy, kitten, and ALPACA (and only them) are here for some positivity. (Speaking of cats: the river TIGRIS is Tygrys in Polish, which means tiger 🐅). Now for my impressions: My effort to solve this unaided was fruitless, and not only because of the countless abbreviations, all of which I ended up looking up, except for PTA. Can you imagine my reaction when I saw the two clues about US school referencing each other? 🤬 That NW corner... "Be up" solving to BAT must be a baseball thing? I have no idea who or what a tax PREPARER is. I only resolved that area with reveals (I only look up proper names, abbreviations and trivia; for regular, unknown words I use reveals, resigning to getting a blue star). I've seen so many terms for a grandmother in these puzzles, but grammy... That's a first. The misdirection in that clue defeated me. Street urchin: GAMIN. That looks like a letter salad to me. I googled some other stuff, too. UTe is a German name familiar to me. I've never seen UTA before, IIRC. ASTI and REM were among my few gimmes. Once I got crosses with all the lookups, I understood the theme. It was fine I suppose, but by that stage I was too annoyed by the fill to appreciate the Thursday gimmick.

43 recommendations21 replies
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNAug 7, 2025, 4:56 AMpositive52%

@Andrzej Don't worry about injecting positivity. On behalf of the vast majority of us on this forum, I saw it too late to fight for your honor yesterday, not that you need help, we heart you just the way you are!! 😁

21 recommendations
SBKTorontoAug 7, 2025, 6:34 AMneutral63%

@Andrzej Not sure if you need explanations or were just venting. In case it's the former: In baseball, when the player's turn to bat arrives, he is said to "be up". A "tax preparer" is one employed by a business that helps you complete and file your tax returns but who has only minimal training and is not a professionally qualified accountant. "Gamin" is a French word that has infiltrated English over many years. It usually refers to a child or teen who presents with a surface innocence but often has a hidden sophistication or sardonic attitude. The stereotypical gamine would be Audrey Hepburn in /Roman Holiday/. Hope this isn't redundant.

5 recommendations
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:40 AMnegative80%

@Andrzej O disappointed again. Thursdays are supposed to be tricky and hard, so I never let them spoil my mood although this one broke my easy streak for this week. That's a Thursday for you. These puzzles are hard in the USA too.

5 recommendations
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYAug 7, 2025, 1:22 PMneutral57%

@Andrzej UTA Hagen was a famous Broadway actress in the mid-20th century, but was also very well known for teaching her craft at an acting studio in NYC. When I lived in Greenwich Village in the late 70s, I passed it every day on the way to work. She was probably better known in NYC than in the rest of the country, not to mention other countries, but she was originally from Germany, so the name is genuine. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uta_Hagen" target="_blank">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uta_Hagen</a>

5 recommendations
ScottSaskatchewanAug 7, 2025, 6:38 AMpositive78%

A year ago I would have given up on this puzzle after the first pass. It took me well over an hour but it's a nice feeling to get it with no lookups. I do wish the theme red herrings (top earners, roman gods, etc) were related in some way to the clue but that's probably asking too much. Nice puzzle!

38 recommendations1 replies
JillSouth FloridaAug 7, 2025, 4:50 PMneutral70%

@Scott, that would have added the chef’s kiss! “Copier cartridge components for the C-suite.” Fishing equipment for Mars and Pluto.”

3 recommendations
john ezrapittsburgh, paAug 7, 2025, 3:18 AMnegative65%

I'm a little sadd because I thought it was MADD. But apparently yeah, Students Against Drunk Driving -- they've recently changed their name -- same acronym but it now stands for Students Against Destructive Decisions. The clue for the Magi has one article too many. I like a good PORE-over LATTE! There's a woman here in town who sneers at hearts -- too easy -- and goes for roses, Mickey Mouse, various Pokemon, Guernica, Mona Lisa... Well. Time to fruitlessly caste for eels in the Tigris.

36 recommendations2 replies
CharlesTip Of the mittAug 7, 2025, 6:02 PMneutral52%

@John Ezra SADD= Campus organization to quell pessimists. Students Against Debbie Downers. :)

2 recommendations
BobNYAug 7, 2025, 2:24 PMneutral50%

I went to Yale, and no one ever mentioned UPenn. The only rival people cared about was Harvard. :-)

36 recommendations4 replies
jenniemilwaukeeAug 7, 2025, 3:14 PMneutral87%

@Bob The constucter's bio mentions a stint at UPenn. So of course, UPenn is on his mind. I always thought of the school as Penn, so I put Brown in at first.

8 recommendations
RozzieGrandmaRoslindale MAAug 7, 2025, 5:23 PMneutral87%

@Bob That is the principal rivalry but there are 7 (I think!) in the Ivy League, so any two can be called rivals.

5 recommendations
Mr DaveSoCalAug 7, 2025, 7:28 PMneutral67%

In sports there is a particular concept of a "rival". For example Michigan and Ohio State are definitely rivals but Purdue and Ohio State are not. A fan would never say all teams that play each other are rivals. But this is a crossword puzzle not a sports article bla bla bla... Whatevs.

6 recommendations
Pratyush GhoshIndiaAug 7, 2025, 12:36 PMnegative69%

While the theme was interesting, the clues are far too heavily weighted towards domain-knowledge and often refer to words and phrases which nobody actually uses. Overall, just felt quite inelegant.

35 recommendations
AnitaNYCAug 7, 2025, 3:31 AMpositive94%

The constructor is my hero because this puzzle is sublime. Well done, Ben! Did you notice the clue that tests our powers of observation? 14A [“Where the the Magi journeyed from” ]

34 recommendations2 replies
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:48 AMpositive98%

@Anita SUB LIME. I love it!

8 recommendations
NickTokyoAug 8, 2025, 5:59 AMneutral90%

@Anita The Magi journeyed afar from the East, but the The Magi journeyed somewhat less far from Anatolia, accompanied by a temporally displaced Mufasa [sic] Kemal Atatürk.

0 recommendations
Nancy J.NHAug 7, 2025, 10:30 AMpositive81%

Great trick! [P.R. piece] for PUERTO - excellent! I had a little trouble parsing PROBLEM ONE at first and assumed it was a foreign word I didn't know. The first thing I thought of after reading the revealer: Tom and Ruth went riding As fast as fast could be. Tom hit a bump at ninety And drove on Ruthlessly.

32 recommendations2 replies
AlexisPerth, AustraliaAug 7, 2025, 2:57 PMneutral63%

@Nancy J. Yes I originally had PROBLEMONE rhyming with Persephone… 😅

5 recommendations
ValerieLos AngelesAug 7, 2025, 2:57 AMpositive99%

Congratulations on your solo debut, Ben! A fun and clever puzzle.

31 recommendations
spuriousSydneyAug 7, 2025, 4:03 AMnegative86%

Brutal. A mix of things I didn’t know and other things I didn’t know. Somehow got there in the end.

28 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYAug 7, 2025, 1:02 PMnegative72%

EELS are increasingly endangered. OPALs can no longer be found in the hot springs of Australia. Sparkling wine has vanished from the shelves of ASTI. NYTimes puzzle constructors are clearly to blame. They grab all they can as soon as they hit the market. HAve AT me, if you wish. It won't EAT AT me. I'm here sipping on my ICEE. (Somewhere UTA Hagen is performing for the UTES.)

27 recommendations1 replies
The X-PhileLexington, KYAug 7, 2025, 2:05 PMnegative79%

EELS on the ELS? Someone IM-ED me with a pic. Ernie ELS is SADD that his time as a crossword clue is off the MAP.

9 recommendations
John PeilSan AntonioAug 7, 2025, 4:19 AMpositive85%

Used to hate these “puzzle” puzzles; now I enjoy them more than any others. Always a gritty mental test for me and always a joy when I can figure out the trick. All that would make this a worthwhile puzzle, but the fact that each of the theme answers make actual words really blows my mind. It’s why NYT is worth the subscription. That and the fact that I know I’m supporting a newspaper that publishes sort of everything I’m AGAINST, generally speaking. And that’s something worth supporting and worth reading. Wish more people understood this.

26 recommendations2 replies
kkseattleSeattleAug 7, 2025, 5:25 AMnegative46%

@John Peil lol. I’ve subscribed to National Review for decades. I think it’s a lost art, figuring out what the other side could possibly be up to.

7 recommendations
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:44 AMnegative76%

@John Peil AGAINST? What? Israel? Zohran Mamdani? IMHO, not enough Pete Buttigieg.

2 recommendations
dutchirisberkeleyAug 7, 2025, 4:45 AMnegative40%

I breezed through this puzzle so quickly!!! Unfortunately, I only came up with two words, so started over. I don't remember where I was in fills when I finally said OK, whatever fits, sense doesn't matter, and started to make a little progress. After I got a couple of answers that made me smirk a bit (e.g., the P in P.R. was for PUERTO), and then FRUITLESSLY emerged so the MANGO popped out, I even started to feel a little cocky. Plowed on, but a still blank squares refused to budge, and in the end, I had to come to the column to get Deb's help. (Thank you, Deb) She said LEMON, so I searched and fixed it, only to be stopped cold again. Oh. A typo. Just what I needed. The puzzle had rewards that were hard won and made it a worthy Thursday challenge, and in the end it was fun. I liked it, and wound up feeling a little less GRAVE(R). Thank you, Ben. See you next time.

25 recommendations
LeapfingerDurham NCAug 7, 2025, 3:08 PMneutral57%

I rode upon my motorbike With PEARs in back of me. I hit a bump at 95 And drove on FRUITLESSLY. Aside from that, anyplace the MANGO, there go I. Thank you berry much, very zaftig, Mister Zimmer.

24 recommendations
Gabriela ONew york CityAug 7, 2025, 4:43 AMnegative71%

This was incredibly difficult. I think this is better as a Saturday crossword

22 recommendations2 replies
JoanArizonaAug 7, 2025, 4:48 AMnegative55%

@Gabriela O I needed seventeen cheats. It could have made a not quite so horrid Saturday or a rather difficult Friday. I was not clever enough to figure out what 'fruitlessly' meant, and am glad for the wordplay explanation.

12 recommendations
SPCincinnatiAug 7, 2025, 1:36 PMnegative71%

@Gabriela O Thursdays can be as hard as Saturday. Saturday solvers are generally expecting hard themeless, if this ran on a Saturday we would have more heart attacks and threats to cancel subscriptions than the editors could deal with.

7 recommendations
BNYAug 7, 2025, 7:46 PMnegative80%

Hi, I'm late to the comments but I have opinions. :) There is much to dislike here for me. I found it a mediocre Thursday. 1. Foremost, the otherwise good theme idea and revealer were underserved by the implemented clues and answers. They were boring and unclever. 2. Self-command, really? 3. Leg armor, really? 4. SADD, really? I assume a relation to MADD but c'mon. 5. Problem one, really? What the deuce. What even is that. 6. So much dreary sports; purported Yale rivalry, obscure quarterback stats, some dude named Vlad... 7. So tired of direction filler like SSE. 8. Dross was good; nice to see. Entirely apart from this particular puzzle, I've noticed an alarming behavior with the web interface. I turn on the timer only once in a very rare time, but I've noticed that it keeps updating long after the puzzle is complete. If I go back to review the thing later in the day, I see numbers like 4:45 and, still later, 5:14 when the game took nowhere near that to complete. (I'm using a mobile Firefox variant.)

21 recommendations1 replies
stephkNYCAug 7, 2025, 11:18 PMneutral83%

@B SADD is Students Against Drunk Driving—it was a popular student-led group at high schools in the 80s, maybe 90s

2 recommendations
BillDetroitAug 7, 2025, 6:50 PMpositive90%

Everyone knows that we have the best elks here in Michigan, much better than Idaho. Everyone is saying it. Beautiful elks. We even know how to pluralize them correctly. If you look at the Great Seal of the State of Michigan, you might think that there are two elks depicted on it, but you would be mistaken--one of them is a moose, although I doubt there are many meese left in Michigan nowadays. Maybe in the U.P. You'll also notice that there are three--count 'em, three!--Latin mottos on the Seal: the official one reads "Si quæris peninsulam amœmam (duasve), stulte, circumspice," Which translates to "if you seek a pleasant peninsula (or two), just look around you, dummy!"

20 recommendations8 replies
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 7:27 PMnegative66%

@Bill It's sad about the moose. When I first moved to the Minnesota North Shore the roads all the way to the Canadian border and beyond had warning signs to be wary of moose. I saw one on the the main road out of Thunder Bay, and I've seen a few along the Gunflint Trail. But it's getting rarer and rarer, and all the warning signs have come down.

3 recommendations
Mr DaveSoCalAug 7, 2025, 7:46 PMnegative78%

@Bill A møøse once bit my sister...

2 recommendations
LCNYCAug 8, 2025, 2:13 AMneutral71%

@Bill I saw some moose on Isle Royale. Which is Michigan. Very up close and personal too. Walked right up on them accidentally.

1 recommendations
AntonyWashington DCAug 7, 2025, 6:38 AMneutral72%

Did anybody else notice the double “the “ in 14A’s clue? “Where the the Magi journeyed from.” Reminded me of that old optical trick on two lines: “Paris in the / the spring.” Almost thought it was intentional. Possibly an editing snafu for “the three Magi”? I believe this may be the first typo I’ve ever caught in the NYT.

19 recommendations9 replies
KevinOmahaAug 7, 2025, 6:44 AMpositive92%

@Antony OMG you're right! Heads should roll!

5 recommendations
AntonyWashington DCAug 7, 2025, 6:48 AMnegative76%

@Antony Serves me right: a typo when pointing out a typo. Should have written: The first typo I’ve spotted in a clue to the NYT crossword puzzle. There are typos galore in the paper, and someone even more waspish and dedicated than me posts them regularly, as many surely know. (@nyttypos) I also noticed after writing my comment that several other people had noticed the typo.

2 recommendations
JeanneSan FranciscoAug 7, 2025, 8:16 AMneutral50%

@Antony LOL, my eyes ran right over it. I tend to see what should be there, maybe because so many of my friends don’t proofread their IMs. I liked that misdirect as I tried EAST and then WEST.

2 recommendations
ΙασωνMunichAug 7, 2025, 9:29 AMpositive96%

@Antony only now that you mentioned it. Cool. 😎 Thanks

2 recommendations
David ConnellWeston CTAug 7, 2025, 10:10 AMnegative55%

@Antony - Muphry’s Law (sic) is a variant of Murphy’s Law, stating that any time a person posts about a grammar or spelling error, the post must inevitably contain a grammar or spelling error.

10 recommendations
CherryGeorgiaAug 7, 2025, 11:58 AMnegative77%

@Antony I caught that too! I’m shocked I tell you! Shocked! 🫢

3 recommendations
Mean Old LadyNow in MississippiAug 7, 2025, 2:03 PMnegative70%

@Antony et alii I think they stopped hiriing proof-readers and to a large extent, copy editors. I didn't notice the typo (probably a missing 'r') and I misread the '50D Fiends'....Friends of folklore (yikes, too many to name!)

2 recommendations
Eric HouglandDurango COAug 7, 2025, 5:16 AMpositive91%

Congratulations on your solo NYT debut, Mr. Zimmer! I review several puzzles each week for Diary of a Crossword Fiend (including those that Brendan Emmett Quigley offers on his website). Just earlier this week, I wrote that I wondered if I would ever again see a crossword puzzle theme that was helpful to completing the puzzle (as opposed to a theme that simply unites varied answers). I’m glad I didn’t have to wait long. Once I got the revealer, understanding the trick here helped me quickly get RO(MAN GO)DS and PROB(LEM ON)E. Thanks for the fun!

18 recommendations6 replies
Eric HouglandDurango COAug 7, 2025, 5:18 AMpositive86%

@Eric Hougland And thanks, Deb, for the nice explanation of the theme.

7 recommendations
Times RitaNVAug 7, 2025, 10:44 AMneutral59%

@Eric Hougland I went to BEQ's website, but can't figure out how to get the puzzles that he offers. Can you help? TIA

0 recommendations
NancyNYCAug 7, 2025, 1:28 PMpositive95%

A delicious puzzle. A theme that's never been done before, never even been thought of before, I'm quite sure, beautifully conceived and beautifully executed. The on-point and original revealer is central to the solve: I wonder if any solver would pick up on the trick if the revealer weren't there. Which is the mark of a super-great revealer. I'm glad that FRUITLESSLY is placed mid-grid. That meant that I could use the revealer to help solve the last two themers. I felt much more involved than I did at 17A, where, looking at TOP EARNERS, all I could do was scratch my head and say "What on earth?" And the cluing throughout the puzzle is first-rate. The importantly situated BUMP and BAT, placed at 1A and 1D, are not at all apparent at first glance. LONG I fooled me yet again. And PUERTO is terrific. Loved this puzzle!

18 recommendations
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNAug 7, 2025, 3:26 AMpositive62%

ALPACAS again, eh!? Pretty suspicious, if you ask me!! Wonder if our favorite alpaca farmer has anything to say for herself!? Hmmm!? 😏 Fun puzzle, but a bit tough for me, which was fun!. Enjoyed it a lot... Almost as much as I enjoyed that mango I ate in the sea that I mentioned a while back when I was in Utila!! 😍

17 recommendations6 replies
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 4:17 AMneutral76%

@HeathieJ You got it. The Alpaca Farmers are giving the NYT kickbacks.

5 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandAug 7, 2025, 5:16 AMnegative93%

@HeathieJ Emus ate my reply here twice now :( They are no fun.

5 recommendations
Niki BBoston, MAAug 7, 2025, 10:59 AMpositive43%

@HeathieJ alpacas are definitely the cutest of these highly suspicious infiltrators!

5 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYAug 7, 2025, 12:53 PMnegative90%

@HeathieJ No wonder that EELS are endangered. The NYTimes keeps gobbling them up!

7 recommendations
Jacqui JRedondo Beach, CAAug 7, 2025, 2:47 PMpositive94%

@HeathieJ my sister wanted to be an alpaca farmer! I’m still waiting for her to finally get them. She bought a 20+ acre farm in Georgia and relocated from California with their 26 chickens, 8 goats, 2 horses and a llama!!🦙 I’m sure the alpacas will arrive soon 🙏🏼😍

3 recommendations
JayCaliforniaAug 7, 2025, 3:53 AMnegative68%

No rebuses. Now nobody will have anything to complain about.

17 recommendations3 replies
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 4:16 AMneutral92%

@Jay You're new here, right?

54 recommendations
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNAug 7, 2025, 4:31 AMneutral66%

@Jay I mean, there are all the conspiracies abounding... Big Rebus is going to have to work harder to keep up!!

10 recommendations
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandAug 7, 2025, 4:39 AMpositive72%

@Jay I saved the day, no worries!

14 recommendations
PhilMonroe, WisconsinAug 7, 2025, 4:10 PMpositive97%

Patting myself on the back. First Thursday puzzle I've solved in a while, not because it was easy, but because I refused to give in too easily. Great fun, and now I'm ready to face the day.

17 recommendations2 replies
KenMadison WIAug 7, 2025, 4:29 PMpositive88%

@Phil Attaboy Phil!

5 recommendations
Niki BBoston, MAAug 7, 2025, 5:01 PMpositive98%

@Phil huzzah!!!

4 recommendations
pollyqwestwoodAug 7, 2025, 2:28 AMneutral64%

most puzzles i'm one of those folks that learns of the theme by reading wordplay. in this puzzle, though, the theme was evident to me and was useful in figuring out the answer problemone. i had prob at the front and the e at the end and maybe another letter or two. so i was reduced to figuring out what fruit would fit in those five letters. in this case i didn't figure out problemone until reading wordplay. variety is good, i guess.

16 recommendations4 replies
Steve LChestnut Ridge, NYAug 7, 2025, 12:07 PMneutral60%

@pollyq I don't feel that PROBLEM ONE is in-the-language the way the others are, but that may just be me. Sometimes, a word or phrase is used within a certain group that I never interact with, and that might be the case here. But I see I'm not the only one who had a bit of a problem with PROBLEM ONE.

4 recommendations
HardrochLow CountryAug 7, 2025, 5:02 PMneutral64%

@pollyq my take on your comment is that you are not much prone to shouting. more soto voce, as it were. ymmv.

3 recommendations
SharonJust off the Fi-Pi-LiAug 7, 2025, 7:24 PMneutral59%

@pollyq Living in Italy as I do, I took "problemone" to be Italian for "big problem". ("Problemino" is "little problem"; "problema" is just plain "problem".) Over here we can augment or diminish anything with the stroke of a suffix!

2 recommendations
RogerSan DiegoAug 7, 2025, 6:03 AMpositive53%

A delightful lady from Texas once told me that for years she believed the Magi were firemen because they came from afar. I sussed it out when I got TOPEARNERS entirely from crosses and tried to parse the clue to that answer. SELF COMMAND seems an unusual phrase to me, GAMIN resides somewhere in my subconscious and I don’t think I’ve ever said PROBLEM ONE but I’m not complaining, I enjoyed the early morning challenge in my hotel room in Devon today.

16 recommendations8 replies
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:29 AMneutral73%

@Roger Shouldn't it be GAMINE?

1 recommendations
JamesTucson, AZAug 7, 2025, 3:44 PMpositive97%

Really enjoyable puzzle! Not at all related, but had Beethoven Sonata No. 22 playing in the background this AM, and got the NYT victory music right as the coda was wrapping up. Apparently both in F Major, as it was the most bizarre yet joyful duet! Happy Thursday all.

16 recommendations3 replies
NYC TravelerNow In Boulder, COAug 7, 2025, 4:32 PMpositive97%

@James, I love this! ❤️

5 recommendations
HardrochLow CountryAug 7, 2025, 6:02 PMpositive85%

@James Of course your comment made me look it up. Spot on. <a href="https://tinyurl.com/3v42h78r" target="_blank">https://tinyurl.com/3v42h78r</a>

3 recommendations
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 7:23 PMnegative56%

I knew GAMIN because when I was young I worked as a copy boy at a local newspaper. One of the reporters was always giving me a hard time (purely in jest). He loved arcane insults, and one day he referred to me as an "insolent gamin". I had to look it up.

16 recommendations
Cat Lady MargaretMaineAug 7, 2025, 4:00 AMneutral54%

I feel there must be a Tom Swiftie lurking in these entries. Like: “Mars and Pluto are my favorite Rods” said Tom, fruitlessly. But funnier? “I can think of a few office holders that need to be IMed” said Tom, fruitlessly.

15 recommendations1 replies
jesSthlmAug 7, 2025, 6:36 AMpositive55%

@Cat Lady Margaret This would make an interesting cipher, especially if reach fruit had some specific extra meaning.

3 recommendations
kkseattleSeattleAug 7, 2025, 5:19 AMpositive57%

Fun puzzle, but it somehow took me forever. I’m better at 5:30 in the morning, with a cup of coffee and the doggo waiting for me to finish so he can get in his first walk and then help me pick the strawberries and tomatoes. (He does the requisite barking and chasing after squirrels.)

15 recommendations6 replies
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandAug 7, 2025, 5:33 AMpositive96%

@kkseattle I loved your post 😍. I can feel your and the doggo's joy 🤩 And it's so cool you still have strawberries! I have very fond childhood memories of picking them in my grandmother's allotment, and in my aunt's and uncle's orchard. In Poland strawberries are considered our national fruit, but they are available only from the end of May to the beginning of July. They are sold in kobiałka, a kind of square, wooden basket. Most Polish households have one somewhere, waiting for late spring. You take an empty one to the farmer's market and get another one with 2 kg of strawberries. Thus the delicate fruit is not transfered from container to container, which would overly bruise it. The Wikipedia article on kobiałka is in Polish only, but I link it for the picture: <a href="https://pl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kobia%C5%82ka_(pojemnik" target="_blank">https://pl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kobia%C5%82ka_(pojemnik</a>)

14 recommendations
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 10:21 PMneutral45%

@kkseattle Quite the helpful dog. I would imagine your having to do the picking *and* the barking and chasing would be burdensome.

2 recommendations
DavidArkansasAug 7, 2025, 9:54 PMnegative79%

Compelled to give this one a big thumbs down.

15 recommendations
JessOntario, CanadaAug 7, 2025, 7:37 AMnegative82%

too many stretches for me. I'm sore.

14 recommendations
kilaueabartOakland CAAug 7, 2025, 4:29 PMpositive76%

Finally noticing what impeachment had to do with chatting online made finishing this puzzle fun.

14 recommendations
SolveradoCOAug 7, 2025, 2:14 AMpositive97%

Pretty quick, but with a neat theme and interesting clues.

13 recommendations
Gina DSacramentoAug 7, 2025, 3:52 AMneutral55%

Had no idea what I was doing. When I finally had enough letters that I thought the answer could be Roman Gods I was able to move ahead. It was like trying to sort things in a closet with the light off. I could hang letters in there that felt like they made sense.

13 recommendations2 replies
Niki BBoston, MAAug 7, 2025, 10:55 AMpositive96%

@Gina D I love your imagery although it makes me want to go shopping. Did you end up liking the puzzle in the end? It was a fun one for me!

2 recommendations
Ian HookhamUkAug 7, 2025, 6:01 AMpositive98%

Really clever theme and once I got the peach I went hunting fruits in the others. Well done really enjoyed it

13 recommendations
RobinOxfordAug 7, 2025, 6:05 AMnegative92%

Ugh. US school rivalries. Tax PREPARER? SELF COMMAND? UNREP? Not my favourite puzzle and not just because of EPILOG.

13 recommendations6 replies
RodColoradoAug 7, 2025, 6:20 AMnegative95%

@Robin UN REP was terrible. Kept thinking it was UN VIP and took me forever to find a workaround.

8 recommendations
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:25 AMnegative61%

@Robin I thought, surely. that the rival school to YALE was going to be HARVARD. But the crosses led to UPENN, so I went with the flow. TAX PREPARER is quite ordinary in the USA, but UNREP seemed a bit disrespectful. It was HALF-ASSED. I hate the spelling of EPILOG. It's much better as EPILOGUE. SELF-COMMAND is meh.

2 recommendations
Times RitaNVAug 7, 2025, 10:40 AMneutral63%

@Robin When I was a kid back in the dinosaur age, we spelled all those words with "ue," i.e. epilogue, catalogue, dialogue. I don't know when it changed, but I still have trouble with them without their endings, and Brooklynese is my first language.

7 recommendations
BobNYAug 7, 2025, 2:28 PMnegative92%

@Robin Living in NYC, the first thing that came to mind was "UN [censored]". People hate them because they abuse their diplomatic immunity to constantly ignore local traffic laws and whatnot.

2 recommendations
ad absurdumchicagoAug 7, 2025, 2:11 PMpositive71%

[Wide rides for the Chicago White Sox?] Great puzzle!! Whether or not you agree with the sentiment, you gotta admit that "Eat the rich" is a much catchier slogan than "Blend the top earners into copier cartridge toner". EELS

13 recommendations1 replies
JohnWMNB CanadaAug 7, 2025, 2:32 PMnegative50%

ad absurdum, At least my counterfeit American money is green.

3 recommendations
BruceAtlantaAug 7, 2025, 2:18 PMnegative51%

I was surprised that 66-across made it into the puzzle. I used the word on which that answer is based in a comment a few days ago when I mentioned the name of a manufacturer of a particularly large type of warehouse fan. The company's name is three words: the first one is "Big," the second word has three letters, and the last word is "Fans." That comment got bumped. Not a big deal...just thought the inconstancy was weird.

13 recommendations4 replies
AndrzejWarsaw, PolandAug 7, 2025, 2:21 PMnegative92%

@Bruce The moderation treating us like little kids in a 19th century Catholic orphanage is ridlculous. Three of my comments did not appear today, who knows why? The "system" is opaque on top of all of its other faults.

16 recommendations
jenniemilwaukeeAug 7, 2025, 3:16 PMnegative76%

@Bruce I'm surprised that 15A got in.

3 recommendations
JillSouth FloridaAug 7, 2025, 4:04 PMneutral91%

@Bruce, I am sure the NYT uses an automated comment moderation plugin across the entire NYTimes.com platform—news and opinion pieces as well as the games. Those typically have a list of words/phrases to block automatically. At least for the first pass, and there may be a moderation team who reviews the blocks (or maybe not).

1 recommendations
ZachPAAug 8, 2025, 1:17 AMnegative90%

WAY too much of this puzzle needs hints. It makes sense if you already know the solutions but trying to get through it without help is a nightmare. I did it, and it took forever, but wow that was not at all satisfying.

13 recommendations
EnglishRoseOld YorkAug 7, 2025, 6:15 AMnegative58%

I needed a lot of help with this one. I had so many false starts: never for GODNO, class for CASTE, nets instead of EELS. I just made it harder for myself and got very confused. It's good for me to remember that we don't all make the same connections in our heads. It all made perfect sense once I had finally completed it, but some of the US specific clues (schools, sports etc) made it difficult to just guess a letter. I am still in awe of anyone who can compile these crosswords (any day of the week). Wakes my brain up every morning.

12 recommendations
AmandalynnMinnesotaAug 7, 2025, 8:42 AMnegative93%

I can’t stand this puzzle.

12 recommendations4 replies
KatieMinnesotaAug 7, 2025, 1:28 PMnegative92%

@Amandalynn I can't stand posts like this.

10 recommendations
RBHTucsonAug 7, 2025, 3:15 PMpositive49%

@Amandalynn Let’s all take a deep breath. Many of us loved this puzzle. Some did not. No prob(lemon) with that.

7 recommendations
MargaretIndianapolisAug 7, 2025, 9:51 AMneutral56%

Problemone? I know, I know, hilariously remove the fruit and it becomes probe. But shouldn't the word with the embedded fruit mean something standing alone? What am I missing (other than an enjoyable puzzle with which to start the day)?

12 recommendations9 replies
MBMaineAug 7, 2025, 10:14 AMneutral53%

@Margaret Sometimes I am the problem one…maybe?

3 recommendations
Mark SmithCharlotte, NCAug 7, 2025, 10:30 AMneutral70%

@Margaret All I could come up with is that it’s the first question to be answered on a math test. I did an Internet search for the phrase and got one link to some song I’d never heard of from 2012, but otherwise nothing seemed to match that phrase.

4 recommendations
The X-PhileLexington, KYAug 7, 2025, 12:44 PMnegative50%

@Margaret I understood PROBLEM ONE to mean "the big, obvious problem that threatens to derail our plans." "Before we institute our re-organization, we have to confront PROBLEM ONE."

9 recommendations
BRNew YorkAug 7, 2025, 12:50 PMnegative66%

@Margaret Agreed. Problem one was way too clunky. This one needed another few weeks of work.

2 recommendations
BNYAug 7, 2025, 8:13 PMneutral59%

@Margaret So it's a rare case where everyone agrees. This one should have been sent back to cook, as @BR indicated. Surprising to find the constructor is so experienced when his or her first puzzle is so whelming.

0 recommendations
KatieMinnesotaAug 7, 2025, 1:34 PMnegative82%

I really have a problem with PROBLEM ONE. It's simply not a thing people say. If it had appeared elsewhere in the puzzle, I'd have been fine with it. But as part of the theme, it falls completely flat. I did enjoy seeing SOOTHSAYERS, though. Forsooth, it was my favorite entry!

12 recommendations9 replies
LarryFNJAug 7, 2025, 1:48 PMneutral81%

@Katie- take out LEMON and the answer is PROBE, as explained in the theme entry; FRUITLESSLY L

2 recommendations
SPCincinnatiAug 7, 2025, 2:03 PMneutral61%

@Katie Yes normally with themes like this the answer should be sort of “in the vernacular” so to speak and this isn’t. I even tried googling it and it didn’t pop up. I sort of imagine it’s analogous to “Job One” which is more common. Still, for tight themes like this I tend not to sweat the small stuff and I can at least imagine someone saying it. Didn’t bother me as much as it did others.

4 recommendations
JonMadison, WIAug 7, 2025, 4:04 PMneutral59%

@Katie I agree with you. That thematic fill at 58A fit faster than the NW corner for me, but “problem one” is not a thing anyone says, so including it in an otherwise well-constructed puzzle was a tiny bit of cheating. Enough so to be worth your comment.

1 recommendations
RozzieGrandmaRoslindale MAAug 7, 2025, 5:33 PMneutral51%

@Katie I agree that "problem number one" is far more likely, but I for one have encountered enough corporate-speak and techie-speak (like @Hanson and @Larry F) to have no argument with PROBLEM ONE. Well a different anti-jargon argument maybe but then again, I'm always extolling the flexibility of English so I'd better be consistent.

4 recommendations
MickPacific NorthwestAug 7, 2025, 6:56 PMneutral78%

@Katie You can't erase me. I exist as a person.

0 recommendations
MarkAlbuquerqueAug 7, 2025, 5:52 PMpositive89%

I thought today’s puzzle was peachy keen. I had no problem with PROBLEMONE. I thought it fit in just fine with the theme, and indeed, it is a phrase I use. I am surprised that many are unfamiliar with it. The phrase is used when a hare-brained scheme with multitudinous and obvious problems is proposed. The most glaring oversight is problem one.

12 recommendations
HeathieJSt. Paul, MNAug 7, 2025, 10:53 PMpositive61%

I had never heard of Rivian before this puzzle. It wasn't even vaguely familiar. Today on my way home from the office, I followed a Rivian half the way home! I considered following him all the way to his home to let him know how exciting it was for me, but I thought that might be a little extreme to share my love of puzzles. Now, it's fair to wonder if maybe I just hadn't noticed seeing one before, but especially since II've been doing the puzzles, I pay more attention to car names because of how often they show up. Rivian didn't even ring a bell! It also felt like the second thing I actually manifested for myself today. The first caused someone to be sick, which was really unfortunate, and I like the person a lot, so I feel bad, but it did get me out of a meeting that I didn't really want to go to. I promise in the future to only use my powers for good!! Still, everything's coming up roses for ole HeathieJ today! Har! I'm so glad I'm not the PROBLEMONE today!! Hehe! And also here to proclaim that I had no PROBLEM with PROBLEMONE. It sounds very normal to me. NOCAP! Har!!

12 recommendations1 replies
Al in PittsburghCairo,NYAug 8, 2025, 2:49 AMneutral65%

@HeathieJ Watching CNBC once in a while will make you aware of Rivian and other young companies. Might even catch them at the IPO.

0 recommendations
LeontionCaliforniaAug 7, 2025, 3:40 AMpositive71%

Somehow convinced myself that "FORGETM" was a short for "aw, forget 'em" ... because it's Thursday. Lol. But then remembered SADD! Fun puzzle!

11 recommendations3 replies
FrancisGrand Marais, MNAug 7, 2025, 3:47 AMneutral77%

@Leontion Exactly my ending as well.

4 recommendations
Jacqui JRedondo Beach, CAAug 7, 2025, 5:49 AMpositive96%

@Leontion I had that as well 🤣 Great minds and all… 😉

2 recommendations
Ms. Billie M. SpaightRichmond Hill, NYAug 7, 2025, 8:46 AMneutral82%

@Leontion I was trying to fit MADD there.

2 recommendations