Tom
Florida
Merer, merer on the wall, What's the lamest clue of all?
This adding letters in one place and subtracting them in another would have benefitted from better cluing, I think.
@Barry Ancona Yes, but they are military terms of art that should be respected. A better clue was called for here.
Minor quibble: an eagle is not a good golf score, it's a great score. It means two under par for the hole.
@Cat Lady Margaret Giddyup may be my favorite thing ever in the crossword. I'm still chuckling.
If you can solve the puzzle easily without getting the gimmick, was there any point to the gimmick?
I always thought "bigwigs" were people of high, if not highest, rank. CEOs, company presidents, managing editors, directors, managers--people with a lot of authority and few, if any superiors. How does a Marine corporal--outranked by several levels of sergeants and all.officers, from 2nd Lieutenant on up--fit that description? (Cuevthe regular Defenders of Every Clue.)
@Laura Stratton I cyberspace, when you scream, no one can hear you.
Not so much a"tour de force" as an ego trip, at least to me. The gimmick doesn't really help with or hinder the solution.
@Cat Lady Margaret The "Fab 5" were freshman basketball players fot the University of Michigan in the 1990s.
@Tom Ah, shoot, I blew the joke. In cyberspace, no one can hear you scream.
@Jere Hallahan Agree completely. I don't get the appeal of these gimmicks. At least I didn't have to figure out how to deal with the shaded Ts. I left them alone and was done in what for me was a jif.
I rarely drop in here. Can someone please explain what "emu" means on this forum? Thanks.
In defense of "righty-tighty , , ," I've always taken it to mean I turn whatever it is--screwdriver, wrench, nut--toward either my right or left shoulder, depending.
@Javafiend Agree totally. It's frustrating to have figured out the clue but not the way to enter it. When it doesn't solve, you wonder if there's a mistake somewhere. Also, entering hyphens via rebus was tedious, but I dididn't see another way, at least on Android.
@Paul I'm not sure it's true that "Stopping By Woods . . ." is not "well known. It may not be taught in high school now, but it was for decades, and those exposed to it will easily recognize "and miles to go before I sleep."
I don't care for gimmicks and I really don't like clues that are factually wrong. The age limit for Little League baseball is 12, not 16, and always has been. It's easy to check. And if you think about it, 16 would be way too old to be competing against 10- or 11-year-olds.
@Isabeau But we have Deb Amlen to explain it!
@Strudel Dad It really works both ways, doesn't it? Like you, my first thought was capita lA Atlas. With the Earth on his back.
@Dan This seems to happen pretty frequently. Years ago, I caught up using them archived puzzles. It was not uncommon, which surprised me.
I thought gimmicks were exclusive to Thursdays.
What is the connection between the puzzle and the photo? Did I miss it?
You know what no one ever says? "Fishing hook."
Isn't what makes an outdoor extension of a house a porch the roof? So "roofed porch" is redundant, isn't it?
@Oaktowner I'm just guessing here, but "peg" as a synonym for "throw" may come from sports writers from baseball's golden era. It was the style, among some, to avoid using the common word. So "home run" became "circuit clout," "left-hander" became "fork-hander," "double play" became "twin killing," and on and on. There were a bunch for "throw," including "wing," "toss," "chuck," "chunk" and "hurl." FWIW, peg as a verb doesn't seem related to peg as a noun, so "hit with," the idiomatic usage you're familiar with, is no more appropriate than "throw."
@Andrzej OK, but I'll bet you have a better idea of how cars and roads are made than you do of how a puzzle is constructed. I know I do.
Hmm. Interesting. I posted a mild critique after I solved this puzzle last night. I found filling it in tedious (though I finished under my average not-very-fast time). I thought it might balance, a bit, what I knew would be abundant positive comments. It wasn't accepted, though ir was not in any way abusive or obscene. Are there wriien standards as to what you can critique?
Does anybody really say "wow" like that? I thought 66A was over-indulge over-indulgent, and being overindulgence-prone myself, I feel qualified to say so.
@Janis @Katya @Beth: Okay, if you say so. But . . . I used a stopwatch app to see how long you'd have to draw out "wow" to match the 15 letters in the answer. The way I would read a w 13 o sounds and another w. I got to more than 7 seconds. But even at half that it seemed unnatural. Especially if the "wow" was, as I interpreted the '?!" punctuation, negative ( or at least snarky).
@Nom De Plume It's a pretty common trope: popped out, flied out, grounded out, fouled out--and the far more familiar struck out--describe how the batter was reired.
@Doug Well," line" does work for the across clues. I knew it would be hyphens, but thought if "line" was entered, once the puzzle was completed, a line might appear.
Help! The puzzle is complete and correct. I've checked it against several online sites. But I keep getting a message that at least one square is incorrect. Do I have a remedy other than hitting the reveal?
@Steven M. Wow, are you wrong. All perfect games are no-hitters. In a perfect game mo batter reaches base. Pitchers have lost no-hitters. Batters can reach base without recording a hit. Teams sometimes score all the runs in an inning without a hit.
@Steven M. Sorry, I misread your post. Apologies.
@Janis I get it. I just think it's self-indulgent. Plus, "oo" is pronounced with a u sound. "Woot" for example. It doesn't sound like "wow." It wasn't that I thought the puzzle was difficult. I saw where it was going. I just thought it was lame.
@Andrzej No, it's salud on my puzzle, crossing with outdo.
@Marlene Thanks for the tip, but mine matches. I guess I'll just give up.
All 39 comments loaded