Selective Walrus

I feel bad saying this, because I’m sure people worked hard to make this puzzle. But it was such an unpleasant experience that I need to voice my opinion: I really didn’t like it at all. I think part of the issue was that the across clues didn’t highlight the relevant downs. So, I was constantly trying to figure out which down was supposed to go with which across. On top of that, one letter in the across answers was irrelevant to the down which made it impossible to read. Then, while it was cute to run with the theme of “stolen” letters. The remaining across fills really should have been actual words. Just really something I hope to never see again. This was a bad idea.

I am on iOS. The underlines did not show up for me. This is like the third time in the last three months, NYT. Get your mobile development team together and figure it out. This is unacceptable (in a “first world problem” kind of way).

Generally disliked. Thought the trick wasn’t worth the squeeze. Knew what the rebus square had to be, but I just didn’t care. Non-American though, so your mileage may differ.

I have to give a big congratulations on the “Shell fish?” clue and answer of GASSTATIONSUSHI. Loved it.

That was fun. Side question: Did someone spike my drink, or is this a Thursday puzzle?

Well constructed and very enjoyable. Had that great Friday quality of feeling overwhelming at first and it slowly whittles away to an excellent sculpted solve.

Waaaay too many names! Sorry but I cannot remember some obscure trivia just to put in LARA or ESSO or IVAN. Really quite absurd.

Brutal, brutal puzzle. Lots of new things which is great, but I take issue with “Get bronze” and not “Get bronzeD”. I also don’t live 37D’s spelling of OMIGOSH. That’s a bit of a stretch. The theme was well executed though, but definitely made it hard.

Tough tough puzzle. Not sure the juice was worth the squeeze on the theme.

It’s unfortunate how easy that puzzle was. Now my personal best Thursday will never be beaten until another unnecessarily easy puzzle comes along on a Thursday. Reasonably fun, but the slavish adherence to the pi day theme put an otherwise easy puzzle on what should’ve been a much harder day.

Solid. Enjoyable. Only one I didn’t love was the clue for BEANIES.

New personal best for a Saturday at just over 9 mins. Is is just me or was that easy for a Saturday?

Nice puzzle. Got any Thursdays though?

I guess I’m in the minority, but I will report that I did not enjoy that puzzle.

As soon as I saw the themer at 20A, I thought “It’d be funny if they…”. They did. One of my absolute favourite movies. New PB though for Mondays since they did this, but I love it nonetheless.

Well, I solved it. I have no idea how the theme clues worked, but I solved it.

Bruuutally hard. So obscure. I appreciate that you’ve constructed this (and the requisite effort), but I did not enjoy this puzzle at all. Glad to not have to see it again.

Tough but fair.

Solid. No complaints. Very cute theme that was Wednesday-appropriate.

Nice Tuesday. Good tension and effort required, but still steadily progressing. Hope everyone had a nice day.

Neat idea! Very nicely done by the art and coding team to pull this off! Fun!

Loved it! Wonderful revealer and theme. Super speedy, and good fun! Welcome to the NYT Crossword!

Easier than usual Thursday, not that I’m complaining. Good fun.

Very fun puzzle, though also a very quick one. Not a PB, but close.

22A is technically incorrect for most extra innings now.

Pretty sure that was too easy for a Friday. Could have been a Themeless Thursday or a Wednesday. New PB for Fridays that I’m unlikely to meet again.

Nice puzzle. I didn’t get the second “spun” answers until the puzzle showed me, but it was an impressive accomplishment.

Nice work! Very fun to solve! One constructive tip: Some reference to Einstein, Hawking or Star Trek to connect it all.

Quick Friday. New PB. Great fun.

A fairly speedy Saturday but there was one thing this Canadian had to look up: Lenny & Larry’s? Never heard of them. Fun puzzle over all. Well done.

Straightforward, speedy and enjoyable. Nice work.

The theme was a good idea. The rest was not pleasant at all. (Sorry)

Cute puzzle! I didn’t appreciate the theme when i was done until i emphasized the “pair”. But i chuckled. Well done.

SAGUARO NYRO POME Wake me up when these words aren’t so obscure (for we Canadians).

Learned a bit about Indian history, geography and cooking in this one.

It took a lot of googling to figure out that BART is Bay Area rapid transit.

Speedy one! Very fun too!

Very fun! Waaaay too easy for Thursday. I should not have a Thursday PB that low.

Cute, but easy. Could have been Friday. I would have reclued more of these. Nice to see “Takes badly?” though. I feel like that clue is crossword royalty.

It’s debatable if ODIE has yellow fur. I would say it’s more beige/off-white.

Breezy and fun for a new PB. Might have been used as a Friday.

I really dislike the clue for of 46 across. It could be any German cry. Why specifically Beethoven? Nothing in Beethoven’s repertoire has anything to do with a cry. Such a weird clue.

Jodphurs eh? All right then.

Very cute reveal after solving. Loved it.

Tough one. Is Sam still running the show while Will recovers?

Didn’t get the theme until I read the column. Yeah okay, well done.