Gary

Amsterdam

116
Comments
0.104
Avg Sentiment
27
Positive
69
Neutral
20
Negative
Sort by:
GaryAmsterdamMay 16, 2025, 8:27 AM2025-05-16positive97%

My streak hit 1000 days today! That is all :)

86 recommendations5 replies
GaryAmsterdamJun 1, 2024, 8:34 AM2024-06-01positive78%

A puzzle is pleasing to me when i pass through the clues the first time and get only a small handful of "maybe" answers, and then it fills up inexorably on repeated passes through. Bonus if some of the first answers were wrong and require repair. Top marks if all this is still completed in reasonable time. This one gets top marks. A pleasant journey.

80 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamFeb 7, 2025, 7:05 AM2025-02-07neutral80%

@Andrzej the reference for many (older) Americans is the theme song from the TV show "The Beverly Hillbillies" Come and listen to my story 'Bout a man named Jed A poor mountaineer, Barely kept his family fed. And then one day He was shootin' at some food, And up through the ground came a-bubblin' crude. Oil that is, black gold, Texas tea. Well the first thing you know Ol' Jed's a millionaire, Kinfolk said "Jed move away from there". Said "California's the place you outta be". So they loaded up the truck And they moved to Beverly. Hills that is, Swimming pools, movie stars.

42 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamOct 17, 2024, 10:10 AM2024-10-17neutral56%

Reading the comments, I'm reminded of the line from Joe Walsh's "Life's Been Good" "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do" <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fds_2qH9sBQ" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fds_2qH9sBQ</a>

34 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamSep 7, 2024, 7:04 AM2024-09-07negative53%

A timelapse of my NW corner would be an ugly thing indeed: strike in place of LAMAZE @ 1A, somehow managed to read [entomologist] instead of [etymologist] @13A, so "insects" lived there quite a while, giving me aces instead of ZIPS @ 5D, Deleted everything, GENEPOOL came to mind and everything slipped into place, thinking "geez this isn't so hard really" These puzzles are always beautiful.

26 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJun 14, 2024, 4:40 AM2024-06-14neutral78%

@Mike Bass'd on recent experience, alto often I mezzo up when I countertenor more.

24 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamDec 15, 2024, 9:24 AM2024-12-15negative49%

When I finally polished this one off, I knew this one was going to be hated and the comments do not disappoint:) If the thieves had been a bit more professional and hadn't left a letter behind, I think it would have been much more tolerable. The extra trick payoff wasn't worth it (I really couldn't even be bothered to try to track down the extra letters and spell them out, to be honest), and it felt kind of damaging, like when the thieves hacked the Vermeer out of its frame at the Gardiner.

20 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamAug 20, 2024, 9:47 AM2024-08-20positive95%

Today is the 731st day of my gold-star streak, 2 years now! After so many days of doing this each morning, every morning, somehow I managed to IDLE through the day yesterday and onto an overnight flight without doing yesterday's puzzle (?!). IRKsome indeed. ANYhoo, frantic efforts to connect before pushback failed, but thanks to onboard wifi I kept the streak alive. MOOD!

19 recommendations1 replies
GaryAmsterdamFeb 13, 2025, 10:58 AM2025-02-13neutral49%

Magnet school focus at 49A and I confidently and quickly put in ARTS at 49A. Silly me, I am not keeping up with the times, STEM is the only thing that matters these days. And maybe not that any more.

18 recommendations5 replies
GaryAmsterdamNov 12, 2025, 9:17 AM2025-11-12negative73%

There can be no peace until they renounce their Rabbit God and accept our Duck God! <a href="https://condenaststore.com/featured/an-army-lines-up-for-battle-paul-noth.html" target="_blank">https://condenaststore.com/featured/an-army-lines-up-for-battle-paul-noth.html</a>

18 recommendations2 replies
GaryAmsterdamSep 19, 2024, 7:55 AM2024-09-19positive52%

@Geoff same for me, exactly. But I was pretty sure that Jason Mraz didn't have a mega-hit about eggs, which is how I ... uh ... cracked it. Gen X ellipsis for the EMU :)

17 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamSep 15, 2025, 9:01 AM2025-09-15positive98%

@Forrest I love sports! Especially when they kick the home run basket!

17 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJan 19, 2024, 9:02 AM2024-01-19neutral66%

@Andrzej A musical "slur" is a curved arc that spans several notes, in order to join them into a phrase, so the musician knows to connect them (as appropriate for the piece and instrument/voice making the music) Read (and see) more/better here: <a href="https://dictionary.onmusic.org/terms/3216-slur" target="_blank">https://dictionary.onmusic.org/terms/3216-slur</a> It's notation for another xword fave: LEGATO :)

16 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamFeb 15, 2025, 7:58 AM2025-02-15neutral85%

@J.S. I confidently put in "necco" but eroded that one letter at a time as the crosses came in.

16 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamApr 1, 2025, 5:15 AM2025-04-01negative55%

At 9D, we could've had a nice ERA/EON swap. How do I know this error? Hmmm.

16 recommendations1 replies
GaryAmsterdamSep 10, 2025, 6:26 AM2025-09-10neutral78%

@John "words to a newborn"

16 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamSep 15, 2024, 8:21 AM2024-09-15positive59%

Lots of fun with the titles. Am I missing something when people don't like having to solve the clues from the crosses? Isn't it a CROSSword puzzle? Cryptic puzzles exist for the purists, I suppose. First pass through, I didn't think this was going to be so exceptional - some misdirects and some self-doubt ... but something clicked and I trusted myself, and I managed to get a personal best time for Sunday out of 4 years of puzzles.

15 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamAug 31, 2024, 6:23 AM2024-08-31neutral80%

@Andrzej Both JAG and "bender" refer to a period (typically, a night) of debauchery, usually alcoholic in nature. There are connotation differences, perhaps. "Bender" is always about alcohol (or drugs), while (for me, at least) a "jag" can be of a different sort, e.g., a "crying jag" is an extended outburst of crying, clearly distinct from a "drunken jag" which is an extended period of drinking. Etymologies are interesting, as far as I could find. One source says "bender" is American English from the mid-19th century. "Jag" is older, and apparently comes from a word for a full wagon load, and "jag" came to mean enough liquor to get drunk, and then to drinking bout itself, and then to the idea of a general outburst akin to a drinking bout.

14 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJul 7, 2025, 7:47 AM2025-07-07neutral45%

@Barry Ancona they invented AM Stereo just in time for no one to listen to it :)

14 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamFeb 15, 2024, 10:24 AM2024-02-15negative70%

I really wanted 27A ("Make Love?") to be notwar or ENDwAR... too many bumperstickers I guess.

13 recommendations2 replies
GaryAmsterdamDec 20, 2024, 9:24 AM2024-12-20positive94%

Another few hundred puzzles and indeed they will go faster, if that's your goal, but there other goals too. I focus on speed, maybe too much sometimes, but it's also nice to smell the flowers, so to speak ... this one had a lot to enjoy. One thing about a really fast solve is that you end up missing 30-40% of the clues.

13 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamDec 28, 2024, 10:28 AM2024-12-28neutral73%

@Patrick J. It seems that Sidney Paget, the illustrator for the original publication of some of the stories, used the deerstalker in his illustrations, so it's canon-adjacent if not strictly canonical (should that be Conanical?) Wikipedia has a photo of Paget in a deerstalker :)

13 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamOct 17, 2025, 8:42 AM2025-10-17neutral65%

@Matt RITAOREOSPEEDWAGON needs to get in a puzzle someday.

13 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamMar 28, 2025, 6:36 AM2025-03-28neutral92%

Could BEEDANCE be a [Hive mime]???

12 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamSep 25, 2024, 8:20 AM2024-09-25neutral61%

@Paul Even for middle-aged crossword puzzling Americans, FDR's dog is obscure, as is the Nevada county. LAREDO, OSU, even ORRIN Hatch ought to be solidly in the memory cells though. The obscurity of clues should challenge anyone regardless of country: secondary Facebook founder, Sumo wrestler, Icelandic poet, secondary Toy Story character, Haitian currency, Time man of the year from 3 decades ago, etc. Maybe some of these are only obscure for me?

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamOct 24, 2024, 11:02 AM2024-10-24neutral54%

My first Ella Dershowitz puzzle, August 2022, came when I was just (re-)starting this whole puzzle thing - it was a Thursday puzzle, it took me 45 (raw) minutes and a bunch of checks. It gave me a bad memory to look at the puzzle again, just remember pulling my few remaining hairs out. Almost 800 puzzles later (and 100 Thursday puzzles, and according to xwstats 5 Ella Dershowitz puzzles later), let's just say I had a much better and smoother experience, and really appreciate the cleverness of the theme and the cluing overall. The rebus misdirect is just the right kind of nasty.

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamDec 21, 2024, 7:15 AM2024-12-21neutral61%

@Andrzej According to one online etymology, the US use of the term to mean "to waver in decision" derives from a Scots verb "waff" which is analogous to "waver." There are quite a few back-engineered etymologies floating around having to do with waffle batter and flippable breakfast foods, but I'm not sold. An early "hack" of the google search algorithm was pulled off during the 2004 US presidential election, when the John Kerry campaign site was the first result when searching for "waffles". This was a response to Bush's White House biography being the first result for a search on "miserable failure" in 2003, perhaps the first google-bombing.

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJan 24, 2025, 10:12 AM2025-01-24neutral62%

@Judith Fairview At age 14 or 15 while learning to type (one had to learn to type relatively late in those days!), I decided my exercise would be to type the theme song for the Brady Bunch as fast as I could. So it is firmly stuck in my muscle memory: This is the story of a lovely lady, who was brining up three very lovely girls. All of them had hair of gold, like their mother, the youngest one in curls. This is the story of a man named Brady, who was busy with three boys of his own. They were four men, living all together, but they were all alone. Till the one day that this lady met this fellow, and they knew it was much more than a hunch, that this group must somehow form a family, that's the way they all became the Brady Bunch!

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 12, 2025, 9:14 AM2025-11-12neutral58%

@Steve The Paul Noth New Yorker cartoon comes to mind: "There can be no peace until they renounce their Rabbit God and accept our Duck God!" best link I could find that works right now <a href="https://norberthaupt.com/2015/11/22/the-rabbit-god-and-the-duck-god" target="_blank">https://norberthaupt.com/2015/11/22/the-rabbit-god-and-the-duck-god</a>/

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 15, 2025, 9:34 AM2025-11-15neutral52%

@Matt while birdwatching in a neighborhood park trail, my wife and I met a woman who asked if we had seen the roc bird. We were a bit puzzled but figured it was a culture or maybe a large hawk. No, she assured us, it was a roc bird from the spirit realm. And that is how I learned about the roc bird!

11 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 6, 2024, 8:16 AM2024-11-06neutral86%

@Harri also 3D, 56D, maybe 7D and 15D, 12D for sure, 35D perhaps?

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 29, 2024, 9:45 AM2024-11-29neutral65%

Why did I decide that Laramie was the capital of Wyoming? Fun fact, it's also at 7200 feet altitude. Fortunately TSA at 19A and an erroneous (but not completely wrong) FuLlS (in place of FELTS) at 29A got me back on the right track... the Atchison, Topeka, and SANTAFE.

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 29, 2024, 1:34 PM2024-11-29neutral84%

@Joe like the old saying goes: - literature becomes sociology - sociology becomes psychology - psychology becomes biology - biology becomes chemistry - chemistry becomes physics - physics becomes mathematics - mathematics becomes impossible

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 30, 2024, 8:17 AM2024-11-30neutral79%

@Clem I looked up the etymology. Some sources seem to say that "error" and "err" come to English from Latin via the old French "errer" The fun part is (at least one source) says that "errer" s actually two identically spelled and pronounced words, with fundamentally overlapping meanings, one of which comes from Latin "errare" (to wander, to stray), and the other comes from Latin iter (road) and iterare (travel). These senses converge in modern English "errant" (and the variant "arrant." I've long had a joke in my head about a pair of two distinct words with separate origins that are homographs (spelled the same), homophones (sound the same), and homonyms (mean the same) simultaneously. I am delighted to have found this example.

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamFeb 12, 2025, 10:35 AM2025-02-12positive82%

@Courtney congratulations! 33 months of madness!

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamMay 20, 2025, 7:36 AM2025-05-20neutral60%

So apparently there were quite a few surveying errors when the borders of Utah were laid out using 19th-century surveying equipment. As you might imagine, the surveyors' chains, telescopes and compasses didn't yield perfectly straight surveyed borders. Indeed if you look at them on an online map you'll see dozens of little jogs and deviations; e.g., the AZ-UT border a bit more than 50 miles east of Page, AZ deviates about half a mile south as you travel towards Four Corners. So Utah is geometrically probably at least a 30-gon. :)

10 recommendations7 replies
GaryAmsterdamMay 28, 2025, 7:40 AM2025-05-28negative87%

This was one for confident errors, 36A "veteran" and 34A "hobOken" tripped me up for a while... Ashamed of the geography on the second one ;(

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamOct 2, 2025, 8:05 AM2025-10-02neutral92%

@Joe P the number indicates how many rebus entries are adjacent to the square with the number. The minesweeper game was a logic puzzle where you figured out where the mines were, by deducing from the numbers where the mines had to be.

10 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 30, 2024, 8:45 AM2024-11-30neutral73%

@Andrzej don't forget the lanai...

9 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamDec 28, 2024, 10:37 AM2024-12-28neutral55%

@Andrzej my wife is learning a little Polish, she would say declensions are deadly rather than vital :)

9 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJan 19, 2024, 9:12 AM2024-01-19positive94%

This puzzle totally clicked for me - after a first pass through that yielded not so much, all those beautiful long answers just popped into my mind one after one, like they were already there. Then I HITASNAG, with my silly little 50A and 44D crossings all wrong, and my brain went out of sync. Fortunately it was just a couple of letters to sort out, and on my way to a nice clean solve, half my Friday average. Nice confidence restorer after a bit of a rough Thursday for me.

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamAug 2, 2024, 8:37 AM2024-08-02neutral47%

So I was happy to know already FLA was the flattest state, but this put Kansas into my mind, so when I got to 47A of course I was smugly sure it was SALINA not SALINAS. Despite this I got SW first and went more or counter-clockwise. "Tough but fair" is my impression, Saturday level for sure.

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamOct 9, 2024, 7:18 AM2024-10-09neutral61%

@Eric Hougland I think "hun" is an acceptable alternative spelling, even if you've fallen out with Attila. "uHNO" for [Gasp] is more of a stretch for me.

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamNov 29, 2024, 9:39 AM2024-11-29positive85%

@Sonja almost certainly breathing! If all goes well I should hit that milestone in May ... in the meantime I go backwards in time in the archives.

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamDec 12, 2024, 9:27 AM2024-12-12positive60%

For me I appreciate any meta-puzzle that includes clue numbers in the answers, not in the clues. At 25A "Beautiful Mind Director Howard": my synapses just connected directly from that clue to "Happy Days" - completely bypassing the name of the director/actor who tie them together, and it took great mental efforts to figure out why "Cunningham" (i.e., "Howard Cunningham," father of Richie, played by RON Howard) didn't fit. And neither did Opie :) Either a symptom of my coffee deficit, or a clever clue designed to befuddle the brains of people who watched the show fifty years ago. Or both.

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJan 10, 2025, 7:46 AM2025-01-10positive91%

@Michael don't forget "many a trial component" @42A which completes a nice trio

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamMay 1, 2025, 8:14 AM2025-05-01positive80%

@Sam Lyons Those two do indeed have a definite turn-of-the-millennium aspect (1st HP film 2001, Finding Nemo 2003). I had young kids at the time, advantage me :) Apparently in this same timeframe, Natick opened its (then-) new arts center in the old fire house, and its high school speech team won 2nd place in the Massachusetts state tournament. Let's remember these facts for a puzzle someday! Those would be True Naticks(tm)

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamMay 28, 2025, 7:32 AM2025-05-28neutral84%

@Anthony if their parents have financial means ... though I have to say, my observation is that the parents are often Swifties too, and not teenage(d).

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamJul 27, 2025, 8:02 AM2025-07-27positive50%

@Paul we used to joke about the "Never tear us apart" video, which featured Michael Hutchence and his romantic interest both with beautiful long dark curly hair, that it should be "they'll never tell us apart"

8 recommendations
GaryAmsterdamSep 9, 2025, 1:28 PM2025-09-09positive83%

@Linda Jo I just put a medicine cabinet into my bathroom :)

8 recommendations