Paul

Oakland

34
Comments
-0.079
Avg Sentiment
5
Positive
21
Neutral
8
Negative
Sort by:
PaulOaklandDec 28, 2025, 7:32 AM2025-12-28neutral55%

I do math for a living and also as a pastime, and have no issue with "mean" and AVERAGE. I do have an issue with the linked article, which is literally nonsense—it reads as if it were regurgitated by an AI from 2 years ago. It's more likely to confuse or turn one off from mathematics than to educate about an unnecessary distinction! Regardless, I enjoyed the puzzle and the notes!

23 recommendations10 replies
PaulOaklandMay 18, 2025, 4:54 PM2025-05-18neutral65%

For five (or more?) months I've been intentionally breaking my streak every month, to avoid the lure of extrinsic motivation

12 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 11, 2026, 10:00 AM2026-01-11positive38%

Liked it. Normally it irritates me to see non-latin glyphs used visually rather than phonetically (e.g. Σ for E, or λ for a) but this use of Φ was a nice exception. I hope some day a constructor braves the calumny of the NYT commentariat to produce a puzzle using 中(文).

9 recommendations
PaulOaklandJun 14, 2025, 1:14 PM2025-06-14neutral63%

I got "baLEEN" very early on, and spent the rest of my time erasing then replacing it.

8 recommendations2 replies
PaulOaklandAug 7, 2025, 10:33 PM2025-08-07neutral71%

Yes, I did; it was only correct on @Barry Ancona 's puzzle.

7 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 11, 2026, 9:30 AM2026-01-11positive84%

@Robert I went through the trouble of installing an Ελληνικά keyboard to have the satisfaction of seeing a Φ, and was pleased to see that it worked.

7 recommendations
PaulOaklandJul 31, 2025, 1:38 PM2025-07-31neutral88%

The plurals of "lacuna" are "lacunae," and "lacunas".

5 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 19, 2025, 5:13 PM2025-10-19neutral93%

@H.E. Puerto Vallarta está en México.

5 recommendations
PaulOaklandJul 18, 2025, 1:33 PM2025-07-18negative89%

Oof. Still picking away, but I don't think I would have recovered from schISt for [ rock with bands ] because how could another word be so similar and specific? No gold for me today.

4 recommendations3 replies
PaulOaklandJul 18, 2025, 1:57 PM2025-07-18positive99%

Whew, and after that reveal the rest of it fell into place. Really liked this one! An impressive flex. Good mix of SAT words and trivia.

4 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 30, 2025, 7:11 AM2025-10-30neutral52%

@Stephen The τ Manifesto is only 15 years old, which explains why you haven't seen it. Your other objections are foreseen and answered by the manifesto. Perhaps to your satisfaction, perhaps not.

4 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 7, 2026, 7:51 AM2026-01-07neutral57%

@Ggb Citation needed! I've eaten 粥 since I was a child. Whether cooked for me, purchased, or prepared by me, it has always been "savory" [sic]. Although, I suspect I have had it unadulterated, before I was old enough to form memories. I'm sure an old timer will eventually comment that clues are clues rather than necessary or sufficient properties of the answer.

4 recommendations
PaulOaklandFeb 20, 2026, 6:51 PM2026-02-20neutral52%

@Anonymous Solomon would have removed the stars altogether

4 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 11, 2025, 3:02 PM2025-01-11neutral91%

@Jane Wheelaghan cell is the indivisible unit; a battery is a group of 1 or more cells; AA is a cell and also (casually) a "single cell battery"

3 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 15, 2025, 2:08 PM2025-10-15negative81%

@Solar Ron have you heard about those people who intentionally let milk go bad and even moldy? The sickly smell is considered virtuous. Some say it's just their version of 臭豆腐 or 腐乳 but I don't buy it

3 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 22, 2025, 4:31 AM2025-10-22neutral61%

The clue "Molecule with a non-unique formula" has it backwards. The answer indicates molecules that happen to have the *same* formula, but have different structures.

3 recommendations6 replies
PaulOaklandNov 9, 2025, 1:10 AM2025-11-09neutral93%

@Eli Edwards the column has a link to instructions. Search for "has a rebus"

3 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 4, 2025, 5:26 PM2025-10-04negative67%

@Bruce I got the pun, but only after filling in the answer. It's not a great pun because, while all fields are trivial algebras, not all algebras are fields. But, it's entirely likely that the word triggered an association which made ALGEBRA pop into my head. So while I intended to come here and whine about it, I decided not to.

2 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 12, 2025, 3:27 PM2025-10-12negative77%

Definitely not a fan of the book spoiler. Statute has not yet expired on that one.

2 recommendations3 replies
PaulOaklandOct 19, 2025, 5:54 PM2025-10-19neutral74%

@Graphic I believe "fuel source" is a good-enough clue for gasoline because it's the kind of thing people might say as a fancied-up synonym for fuel. That said, S's prescriptivist point is: Gasoline is a fuel, and the source of that fuel is petroleum. ICE is not a fuel, so it doesn't have (that kind of) a fuel source. An ICE uses fuel and the source of that fuel is the gas tank. (Or line, but that's stretching it)

2 recommendations
PaulOaklandNov 4, 2025, 6:08 AM2025-11-04negative82%

@Francis calling puns and metaphors "lies" is an unexpected judgement to find on a forum dedicated to wordplay. Good luck getting mathematicians to stop punning. And besides, all numbers are unreal, even ℝ. "ℕ symbolizes things and ℝ quantity, but ℕ and ℝ are better than things and quantity. Otherwise they would degrade the things they symbolize."

2 recommendations
PaulOaklandAug 3, 2025, 12:56 PM2025-08-03neutral50%

@Fred logically speaking, that's the fallacy of denying the antecedent. "I guess if you like Star Trek, you lived during the era of television. I don't, so I didn't." (Also the initial syllogism is unfounded, but why worry about epistemics)

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 15, 2025, 3:03 PM2025-10-15neutral87%

@Sam Lyons and wggwg , for academic interest: a digraph is two graphemes, which is only important when (as you pointed out) the relationship between letters and graphemes is unusual, or in flux, or both. This doesn't invalidate anyone's arguments that the clue is correct. It's correct because "head" is intentionally ambiguous and could refer to one (or more) letters, graphemes, syllables, phonemes, ... . "letter" arises from Sam, who in fact took Patrick's position that ll was still a single letter: "the “head,” i.e., first letter, [...] is a pair of ELS."

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 15, 2025, 3:19 PM2025-10-15neutral81%

For more academic interest, taking a computer rather than linguistic approach: Unicode sometimes has codepoints for ligatures (e.g. IJ ), for compatibility reasons. But to my knowledge there is not one for LL. And even if there were, in "NFKD"* ("Decomposed" Normal Form) that hypothetical compatibility codepoint would decompose into 2 codepoints, which you would describe as ELS. * For the Unicode pedants: but not in NFD, I checked

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 23, 2025, 6:55 AM2025-10-23neutral61%

The clue as written strongly implies that "Some" and NOT ALL are synonymous; but they're not. That's why the phrase "Some but NOT ALL" exists.

1 recommendations6 replies
PaulOaklandDec 26, 2025, 7:11 PM2025-12-26neutral91%

@Xword Junkie obi are used for men's clothing as well

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 10, 2026, 7:34 PM2026-01-10negative84%

@Mu I agree that WATER HORSE doesn't make no sense. It makes at least two: kelpie and hippopotamus.

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 15, 2026, 9:01 AM2026-01-14neutral74%

@Logan Whalen it literally means garlic and oil.

1 recommendations
PaulOaklandApr 3, 2025, 1:45 AM2025-04-02neutral79%

@Jairus No; that's a truck. A pan is a rotation.

0 recommendations
PaulOaklandJul 6, 2025, 6:36 PM2025-07-06negative63%

@The X-Phile you are correct that their dismay is dismaying; in the same way would I be dismayed if someone felt they had to eat a disliked cherry in order to "finish" their sundae. I blame it on the parent who gives out gold stars to those who finish their meals. But at least said parent does it for the benefit of their child, as opposed to the grey lady who does it to drive engagement and revenue.

0 recommendations
PaulOaklandOct 17, 2025, 1:53 PM2025-10-17positive97%

On the easier side. Pretty fun.

0 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 11, 2026, 9:17 AM2026-01-10neutral72%

@Mike a bit of Latin, Greek, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Turkish, Hindi, Urdu, Hawaiian, Inuit, Cree, and mathematics wouldn't hurt either.

0 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 15, 2026, 9:09 AM2026-01-14negative66%

@10034 it's not so much judgement, as a cynical way to increase engagement by supplying a source of extrinsic motivation while simultaneously reducing people's enjoyment

0 recommendations
PaulOaklandJan 26, 2026, 5:59 AM2026-01-25positive91%

Apple TV thriller that received 27 Emmy nominations for its second season

0 recommendations

All 34 comments loaded