David Hancock

NYC

39
Comments
-0.246
Avg Sentiment
10
Positive
7
Neutral
22
Negative
Sort by:
David HancockNYCJun 30, 2024, 10:59 PM2024-06-30neutral50%

This probably won't get past the moderators but here goes. A note on general civility. Like many I occasionally like to grouse about crosswords that in my opinion miss the mark -- too arcane, heavy handed, whatever. Not all crosswords are created equally. Inevitably there are a couple frequent posters -- you know who I mean -- who swoop in to defend the crossword. The crossword doesn't need defending, they have our money, life will go on. But these guardian angels of the grid are often irksome and condescending. It's just a different opinion, okay? Not every differing thought has to be corrected. Thank you. Please let this go through, others probably feel the same.

47 recommendations9 replies
David HancockNYCNov 9, 2025, 6:40 PM2025-11-09negative88%

The leap from Western Union to state abbreviations is so broad that even Evil Knievel couldn't jump it! This was a tiresome puzzle. Blech!

38 recommendations
David HancockNYCMar 30, 2024, 4:23 PM2024-03-30neutral77%

@archaeoprof It was opaque to a lot of us

20 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 30, 2024, 9:10 PM2024-06-30negative75%

I dunno. Hated Saturday and now I hated Sunday too. Everyone seems to love it so I guess I'm out of synch with some of these great crosswords. Words like vergeinyeah are just gibberish to me. Aren't they supposed to mean something on their own even if there's a double meaning?

20 recommendations8 replies
David HancockNYCJan 28, 2024, 6:10 PM2024-01-28positive96%

Cute graphics, fun finale for decently difficult puzzle

16 recommendations
David HancockNYCJan 30, 2025, 5:15 PM2025-01-30positive94%

My favorite thing! Figuring out the gimmick halfway through and having it help me fill. Versus my usual MO of somehow finishing without getting the theme.

16 recommendations
David HancockNYCSep 8, 2024, 3:46 PM2024-09-08positive80%

After whizzing through the first ten minutes I thought it was an oddly easy Sunday puzzle. But then it dragged! As others noted "ol " without the e was a stretch. But generally enjoyable. Anytime I get done with Sunday in under an hour with no help is a win!

14 recommendations
David HancockNYCAug 12, 2024, 2:54 PM2024-08-12negative75%

I complain when they're too hard and I complain when they're too easy. There's no pleasing me!

11 recommendations1 replies
David HancockNYCApr 4, 2024, 2:53 PM2024-04-04negative59%

I thought it a bit easy for a Thursday but I bogged down at the end. Those letter Qs, you never think of them

9 recommendations2 replies
David HancockNYCApr 6, 2024, 3:43 PM2024-04-06negative64%

Um not gonna spend all morning on this one, that's for sure

9 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 19, 2025, 6:50 PM2025-06-19negative90%

Hated it! So random, take letters from other words and put here or there. What is a parade rest?

9 recommendations1 replies
David HancockNYCJan 4, 2026, 5:34 PM2026-01-04negative82%

So many baked in errors. I kept fixing one by one, but there was always one (or more) out there. Time for a walk!!!!

9 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 8, 2024, 4:55 PM2024-06-08negative86%

It's been a while since I was quite as stumped before turning to the column. Nothing egregious to complain about but didn't enjoy the randomness of the answers. Goss is not really a term that people use. You'd think "Age of ....." would make you smile, but I found it annoying. Maybe just me

8 recommendations9 replies
David HancockNYCAug 29, 2024, 3:35 PM2024-08-29positive97%

What a satisfying moment to go from completely in the dark on the concept to aha! The revealer was IK which I had put in before partially. Plural of senators robes a bit much but all in all one of my favorite Thursdays ever

8 recommendations
David HancockNYCAug 3, 2025, 5:11 PM2025-08-03positive89%

Speaking g as a boomer, this was fun! I bogged down at the end and had to UNDO a corner.

7 recommendations
David HancockNYCAug 20, 2025, 4:05 PM2025-08-20negative83%

Clue: When a crossword theme proves to be no help in solving individual crosses and is a hardly a "delightful solve." Answer: Underwhelming

7 recommendations1 replies
David HancockNYCSep 17, 2025, 4:33 PM2025-09-17negative44%

Well glad I looked at the hints instead of spending an hour on something I never would have gotten

7 recommendations
David HancockNYCOct 16, 2025, 3:11 PM2025-10-16positive98%

So fun to figure out the theme midway and use that to fill. Enjoyed this!

7 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 29, 2024, 8:36 PM2024-06-29negative95%

"Brisk and enjoyable" ? How about tedious and annoying? Filled with random answers that aren't cute or apt. Hated it! Not gonna Google it, I quit!

6 recommendations3 replies
David HancockNYCOct 2, 2025, 2:50 PM2025-10-02positive83%

So many times I'll lumber through a solve without figuring out the theme. What fun when recognizing the theme helps with problematic solves. This was fun

6 recommendations
David HancockNYCJul 7, 2024, 5:22 PM2024-07-07positive94%

Well it was a slog for me with lots of prompts to keep going but the magical display at the end was fun

5 recommendations
David HancockNYCMay 8, 2025, 2:53 PM2025-05-08negative71%

Once I realized that some of the words had letters outside the grid I thought no, hard pass. Life is too short

5 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 6, 2024, 4:43 PM2024-06-06negative87%

S****l? That's rough 🤪

4 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 30, 2024, 11:21 PM2024-06-30negative56%

@Francis But why would you get worked up into righteous anger over a crossword comment board? Live and let live!

4 recommendations
David HancockNYCApr 13, 2025, 3:35 PM2025-04-13neutral72%

Orange one sitting on me when I solved that clue

4 recommendations
David HancockNYCJun 29, 2025, 8:14 PM2025-06-29negative62%

A bit of a slog

4 recommendations
David HancockNYCMay 6, 2024, 1:33 PM2024-05-06neutral92%

Little Havana is a neighborhood in the city of Miami. South Beach is a neighborhood of the city of Miami Beach. People say "Miami" when they mean Dade County.

3 recommendations1 replies
David HancockNYCJul 14, 2024, 7:13 PM2024-07-14negative48%

I wish I would have noticed the crossword title on the launch page, would have saved me some time. Was thinking the six key phrases weren't very clever word salad and then it dawned they were actually very clever

3 recommendations
David HancockNYCJul 20, 2024, 4:57 PM2024-07-20negative80%

I don't understand ross as supreme leader

3 recommendations5 replies
David HancockNYCFeb 4, 2024, 5:33 PM2024-02-04positive89%

This was a nice pleasantly hard puzzle for an hour with coffee. Time to get out of the bathrobe!

2 recommendations
David HancockNYCNov 8, 2025, 5:20 PM2025-11-08negative84%

Sometimes I feel like a wimp for reading the hints but today I'm glad I saved myself another hour. I was deeply committed to toothache and nothing was coming together in SE corner 😒

2 recommendations
David HancockNYCNov 8, 2025, 5:55 PM2025-11-08negative68%

@Nathan I had toothache for so long

2 recommendations
David HancockNYCDec 14, 2025, 9:36 PM2025-12-14positive82%

From cray to craw to crab ... I finally got there. Was a slog but had some amusing entries

2 recommendations
David HancockNYCOct 4, 2024, 3:50 PM2024-10-04negative88%

Where are the links to this column in your new app?!? I've had to google it to find it. Please fix!!

1 recommendations
David HancockNYCApr 10, 2025, 4:37 PM2025-04-10negative92%

I guess I'm stressed out in general because I hated this one. Dripping in urban areas was unsolvable and like many I had Eminem ( and Eli crossing) which was problematic. Oopsie was a bit much. I gave up because I was t having fun with the arcane theme

1 recommendations2 replies
David HancockNYCMay 8, 2025, 3:12 PM2025-05-08neutral78%

@Felix messy is right

1 recommendations
David HancockNYCJul 13, 2024, 6:30 PM2024-07-13neutral66%

@Seward Parker Yes that was the last to fall for me too

0 recommendations
David HancockNYCMay 7, 2025, 2:01 PM2025-05-07negative72%

@CNS I still don't understand it is Amos short for something

0 recommendations
David HancockNYCJan 4, 2026, 5:16 AM2026-01-03neutral50%

@Barry Ancona No you didn't you used a shovel

0 recommendations

All 39 comments loaded